DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 184 KB)
The Sequence of Berachot When Eating Cake With Coffee

When one eats cake with coffee, he of course recites two Berachot: "Mezonot" over the cake, and "She’ha’kol" over the coffee. (This assumes he drinks the coffee separately; if he dips the cake into the coffee, and does not drink the coffee on its own, then he recites only "Mezonot" over the cake, and this covers the coffee absorbed by the cake.) According to the standard rules governing the sequence of Berachot, a person in this case should first recite "Mezonot" and take a bite of the cake before reciting "She’ha’kol" and sipping the coffee. Given the rule that more specific Berachot precede less specific Berachot, it would certainly appear that the cake should precede the coffee in such a case, and this is, indeed, the ruling of Hacham Ovadia Yosef in his Yabia Omer.

However, Hacham Ovadia’s son, Hacham David, in Halacha Berura, posits a novel theory – that in such a case one should first recite "She’ha’kol" and sip the coffee before reciting "Mezonot" and taking a bite of cake. He explains that there is a minority view among the Poskim that when one drinks coffee with cake, the coffee is considered "Tafel" ("secondary," or "subordinate") to the cake, such that the coffee is covered by the Beracha recited over the cake. According to this view, since one’s primary intent is to eat, and the coffee is drunk only because the cake is dry, the coffee does not require its own Beracha, and it is included in the Beracha recited over the cake. Although Halacha does not follow this opinion, Hacham David asserts that it is preferable to avoid this Halachic dispute by first reciting a Beracha over the coffee and taking a sip, before reciting the Beracha over the cake. And although "Mezonot" always precedes "She’ha’kol," Hacham David notes the position taken by the Ritba (Rav Yom Tob of Seville, Spain, d. 1320), in a recently-published manuscript, that this rule applies only when one eats two foods requiring these two different Berachot, but not when one eats a food and drinks a beverage. In the latter case, according to the Ritba, there is no preferred sequence, and one may either partake first of the food or first drink the beverage. In light of this position, Hacham David reasons, it is preferable when eating cake with coffee to first recite "She’ha’kol" over the coffee and then recite "Mezonot" over the cake. Hacham David asserts that if his father had seen this position of the Ritba, he would have reached this same conclusion.

Of course, this is not the conventional opinion. Regardless, as for the practical Halacha, both views are valid, and one may choose which one to follow.

Summary: When one eats cake with coffee, the conventional practice is to first recite "Mezonot" and eat some cake, and then recite "She’ha’kol" and take a sip of coffee. According to one opinion, however, one should reverse the order, and first recite "She’ha’kol" and sip some coffee before reciting "Mezonot" and partaking of the cake. Both opinions are valid.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
If the Hazan Forgot to Recite Ya’aleh Ve’yabo During the Repetition of the Amida on Rosh Hodesh
Should Two Kaddishim be Recited if a Shiur is Given Immediately Before Arbit?
Reciting “Yiheyu Le’rason Imreh Fi” at the End of the Amida
The Kaddish Before Baruch She’amar
The Value of Praying “Vatikin” and Studying Torah Before Prayer
The Importance and Significance of Birkat Ha’lebana
The Custom Among Syrian Jews Regarding the Text of “Ve’la’minim” and Other Portions of the Amida
Adding Prayers for Forgiveness and for One’s Livelihood in “Shema Kolenu”
If One Mistakenly Recited “Morid Ha’tal” Instead of “Mashib Ha’ru’ah U’morid Ha’geshem”
Should a Mourner be Called for an Aliya if He is the Only Kohen in Attendance?
May Birkat Kohanim be Recited if a Non-Jew is Present
If a Kohen Was Mistakenly Called for the Second Aliya; Calling Kohanim for Later Aliyot
How Should the Aliyot be Arranged in a Minyan of Only Kohanim, or if There is Only One Yisrael?
Birkat Kohanim – The Hazan’s Announcement of “Kohanim”; If There is One Kohen or No Kohanim Present
Birkat Kohanim in a Place Without a Sefer Torah; One Who Enters the Synagogue During Birkat Kohanim; Reciting Birkat Kohanim Several Times in One Day
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found