DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is In Memory of
 Dr. Henry Briggs
"Dr. Henry Briggs M.B. B.S. F.R.C.P. Consultant Physician, Cardiologist, and numerous qualifications in Anti-Ageing Medicine. A little refugee boy who survived war-torn Europe and arrived in Sydney Australia with no English."

Dedicated By
Mr & Mrs Isaac Moses

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 538 KB)
Selecting and Removing Undesirable Grapes From a Cluster on Shabbat

If on Shabbat a person wishes to serve a cluster of grapes for dessert, and he sees that several grapes are dried, spoiled, or otherwise undesirable, may he remove the grapes before serving the cluster?

One of the conditions for allowing Borer (separating) on Shabbat is that one may remove only the "Ochel" (desirable food) from the "Pesolet" (undesirable substance). It is forbidden on Shabbat to remove the "Pesolet" from the "Ochel." Seemingly, then, it would be forbidden to remove the spoiled grapes from a cluster, since this would be removing the undesirable food from the desirable food.

However, Rabbi Moshe Halevi (Israel, 1961-2001), in his work Menuhat Ahaba, rules that one may remove the spoiled or unattractive grapes from a cluster on Shabbat. He notes that there are several factors which, taken altogether, provide a sufficient basis for ruling leniently in this regard. For one thing, Rabbenu Hananel (early 11th century) was of the opinion that the prohibition of Borer applies only to items that are detached from one another but mixed together. In his view, the prohibition does not apply to items which are attached together, as they constitute a single entity, and thus removing some items is not considered "separating." Secondly, Rabbi Moshe Halevi cites authorities who claim that removing spoiled grapes from a cluster is considered "Derech Achila," the normal, standard method of eating grapes, and Borer is allowed when it is done as part of the usual manner of eating.

It should be noted, however, that this Halacha refers only to removing grapes from the surface of the cluster. If a person sees undesirable grapes on the external layer of grapes, then he may remove them, but he should not go searching through the cluster for the rotten or unseemly grapes. Furthermore, removing unwanted grapes is allowed only just before serving the cluster. One may not remove the undesirable grapes in preparation for a dessert that he will be serving later on during Shabbat.

Summary: It is permissible to remove spoiled or otherwise unwanted grapes from a cluster on Shabbat, provided that this is done just prior to serving the cluster. However, one should not go searching through the cluster for unwanted grapes; he may remove unwanted grapes that he sees on the surface of the cluster, but should not specifically search for grapes that should be discarded.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Taking Fertility or Birth Control Pills on Shabbat
May a Doctor Receive Payment for Medical Services Provided on Shabbat?
Violating Shabbat for a Woman and Newborn After Childbirth, and for Fetal Distress During Pregnancy
Violating Shabbat to Care for a Woman After Childbirth
Violating Shabbat For the Sake of a Woman in Labor
Resuscitating an Unconscious Patient on Shabbat
Using Suppositories or an Enema on Shabbat
Taking A Blood Test on Shabbat
Exercising on Shabbat
The Use of a Baby Monitor on Shabbat
Food Cooked by a Gentile on Shabbat for an Ill Patient
Turning Off a Light for an Ill Patient on Shabbat
Desecrating Shabbat to Help a Frightened Child
Violating Shabbat to Treat a Fever
Desecrating Shabbat for a Tetanus Shot or After Ingesting Something Sharp or Toxic
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found