DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 700 KB)
Is It Proper To Join The Minyan or Appropriate To Start At The Beginning When Arriving To Shul Late At the Time of Amidah

Just one Halacha that comes out of the Gemara in Berachot, Daf 4. The Gemara there says ‘Eze Hu Ben HaOlam Haba, Ze HaSomech Geula L’Tefilah’. The Gemara is saying that those who go from the prayer of Ga’Al Yisrael straight into the Amidah, will merit in the world to come (Olam Haba.) So the question was asked if one should join in with the Minyan as they start the Amidah if he is late, or should he start his prayers from the beginning in order to keep to this desired sequence of Ga’al Yisrael preceding the Amidah.

In Shacharit, keeping to the sequence is a strict rule. So if a person would walk in late right at the end of the prayer ‘Ezrat Avotenu’ (which is the prayer of Ga’al Yisrael), he should start at he beginning of Tefilah and not join in with the Minyan in the Amidah. It would be more important for him to say Shacharit in the proper sequence and read the entire prayer of ‘Ga’al Yisrael’ followed by the Amidah, than to join in with the congregation and miss the sequence.

So now the same question is asked about Arbit. Should one join in and say the Amidah if he is late and misses the prayer of ‘Ga’al Yisrael’, and say the Berachot of Arbit and Kriat Shema afterwards? Or should one start at the beginning of Arbit and end up praying the Amidah alone? To answer this question, we need to analyze if the sequence of "Ga’al Yisrael’ followed by Amidah is equally as important as in Shacharit.

Maran writes in Shulchan Aruch siman 235:2, that one should not make in interruption in Arbit. So seemingly, Maran is concerned in Arbit as well that one should keep to the sequence without interruption. Maran in the following Halacha however brings up this issue in particular, and says that by Arbit a late comer should not start at the beginning but rather join in with the Minyan if they are about to say the Amidah. Maran says that it is better to pray the Amidah with the Minyan and then say the Berachot of Arbit and the Kriat Shema afterwards. He points out that in Arbit, the sequence of ‘Ga’al Yisrael’ followed by Amidah is not as vital as in the morning.

To review, there is a difference between Shacharit and Arbit. In Arbit, Amidah with the Minyan overrides ‘Geula L’Tefliah’. But, in Shacharit saying the prayer of ‘Ga’al Yisrael’ right before the Amidah overrides Amidah with the Minyan.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Nidda – The Status of Stains Found on Colored Garments
Immersing in a Mikveh With Long Nails and Nail Polish (Part 2)
Immersing in a Mikveh With Long Nails and Nail Polish (Part 1)
If a Woman Did Not Immerse In The Mikveh on the Night After the Seventh Day
May a Woman Immerse in the Mikveh Before Sundown on the Seventh Day?
When May a Woman Begin Counting the Seven “Clean Days”?
If No Wine is Available Under the Hupa; The Recitation of Birkat Erusin
The Custom to Refrain From Eating Meat On the Day of Immersion In A Mikveh
Weddings in Synagogues
Laws and Customs of the Meal at a Wedding
Does the Officiating Rabbi Drink the Wine Under the Hupa?
Who Has the Right to Choose the Officiating Rabbi at a Wedding?
If the Sheba Berachot Were Recited Out of Order
The Great Rewards of Hachnasat Kalla – Helping a Couple Marry and Build a Home
Must the Hatan’s Family Lineage Appear in the Ketuba?
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found