DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 700 KB)
Chanukah- Should One Say Mezonot On A Fried Jelly Donut That Is Eaten For Dessert

The Minhag on Chanukah is to eat foods that were fried in oil. It seems that this is part of the remembrance of the miracle that took place with oil. There is also a custom to eat donuts, more specifically jelly donuts that are fried. So it is worthy to say one Halacha regarding the jelly donuts.

Is the Beracha of Mezonot required before eating jelly donuts if it is the dessert of a meal for which you washed and made HaMotzih?

We are familiar with the Halacha that says the HaMotzih covers most foods that are used for dessert. This includes normal Mezonot items like cakes and cookies. The HaMotzih covers these items because we are not sure if they are definitely considered "Pat Haba'a Be-Kisnin", which is when we say Mezonot. Now there is a debate as to what constitutes "Pat Haba'a Be-Kisnin." Some Rabbis say it is considered "Pat Haba'a Be-Kisnin" when it is kneaded with honey or sugar like a cookie. Others say it is when the food has the properties of a pocket type structure like a turnover. And yet others say it is when the food is crunchy like a pretzel. So since there is doubt as to which of these constitute a Mezonot, we therefore accept upon ourselves that the HaMotzih covers desserts such as cakes, cookies, turnovers, pretzels, etc. (For further understanding of this, please see the Daily Halacha entitled "When One Must Say Birkat Mezonot after saying Birkat HaMotzih.")

However, with regards to the fried jelly donut, there is no controversy among the Poskim. A jelly donut qualifies as a definite Mezonot. Firstly because it is fried and according to most Poskim, fried makes it a Mezonot. Furthermore it is sweet and the property of a pocket. Therefore it qualifies as a Mezonot even after one made HaMotzih in the seuda.

Halacha Lema'ase, according to the Birkat Hashem in Helek 3, Page 375 (written by Rabbi Moshe HaLevi), if one is eating a fried jelly donut as a dessert to a meal for which he washed and made HaMotzih, he nonetheless must make a Mezonot because the HaMotzih does not cover the jelly donut.



 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Simhat Hatan Ve’kala – Bringing Joy to a Bride and Groom at Their Wedding
Are Sheba Berachot Recited for a Second Marriage?
Should Weddings be Scheduled Specifically During the First Half of the Month?
Understanding the Nature of Birkat Erusin
Under What Circumstances Does a Forbidden Marriage Take Effect?
Marrying One’s Wife’s Sister After Death or Divorce
May the Daughter of a Jewish Woman and Non-Jewish Father Marry a Kohen?
Situations Where a Pregnant or Nursing Woman May Remarry Immediately After Being Widowed or Divorced
Under What Circumstances May a Divorced Couple Remarry?
How Soon May a Widow or Divorcee Begin Dating?
The Importance of Following the Proper Halachic Procedures When Getting Divorced
Peru U’r’bu – Marrying an Infertile Woman; Delaying Marriage; Adopting Orphans; If a Convert Had Children Before Conversion
Nidda – The Inspections During the “Seven Clean Days”
The Prohibition of Relations With a Non-Jewish Woman, and With One’s Wife’s Immediate Relatives
Nidda – When is the Proper Time of Day For the Hefsek Tahara Inspection?
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found