DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 808 KB)
Violating Shabbat to Administer Medical Care to a Critically Ill Patient

The famous Halacha of "Piku’ah Nefesh" establishes that the concern for a Jew’s life overrides the prohibitions of Shabbat. The laws of Shabbat may, and in fact must, be violated when this is necessary to save the life of a seriously ill patient. It is critically important for people to acquaint themselves with the detailed Halachot of "Piku’ah Nefesh," as when such situations arise, people do not normally have the opportunity to begin searching through books to find the Halacha. These Halachot must be learned so that when one finds himself in a situation of a critically ill patient in need of urgent care, Heaven forbid, he will know exactly what should be done.

The custom of the Sepharadim, following the ruling of the Shulhan Aruch, is to have specifically an adult, Jewish male violate Shabbat in situations of "Piku’ah Nefesh." If the job is assigned to a gentile, people might mistakenly conclude that a Jew may not violate Shabbat to save a life. Similarly, if the job is assigned a woman, people might think that men should not violate Shabbat in situations of "Piku’ah Nefesh." The same concern arises if a child is given the task, which might give the impression that adults may not transgress Shabbat for "Piku’ah Nefesh." Therefore, according to Sephardic practice, specifically an adult Jewish male should be called upon to violate Shabbat for the sake of helping a critically ill patient. (It should also be noted that a Jew would presumably exert himself more fully to help a fellow Jew than a gentile would, and for this reason, too, it is preferable for a Jew to tend to the patient’s needs.)

Interestingly enough, the Rambam (Rabbi Moshe Maimonides, Spain-Egypt, 1135-1204) goes even further, claiming that the most righteous man available should be the one chosen for the purpose. In order to impress upon people the importance of saving a Jewish life, according to the Rambam, the greatest Rabbi available should be called upon to violate Shabbat to tend to a critically ill patient.

Hacham Ben Sion Abba Shaul, in one of his published responsa, qualified the Shulhan Aruch’s ruling requiring an adult Jewish male to violate Shabbat in cases of "Piku’ah Nefesh." He writes that this applies only to the actual administering of medical treatment, such as turning on machines, preparing the intravenous feeding system, and the like. When it comes to needs that are not directly related to administering treatment, however, then it is preferable to either ask a gentile to perform the action in question, or for a Jew to perform the action with a "Shinui" (in an unusual manner). For example, if a heater or light needs to be turned on in the patient’s room, then a gentile should be asked to turn the switch, or a Jew should do so in some unusual manner, such as with his elbow. By the same token, if a prescription must be written, this should be done by a gentile, or by a Jew in an unusual manner.

Summary: If a critically ill patient requires emergency medical care on Shabbat which entails violating the Shabbat prohibitions, an adult, Jewish male should be called upon to perform the acts in question, to emphasize the point that the concern for human life overrides the Shabbat prohibitions. This applies, however, only to the actual administering of medical care. When it comes to secondary needs such as turning on a heater or writing a prescription, it is preferable to either ask a gentile or for a Jew to perform the act in an unusual manner.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Chanukah- May a Traveling Man Light in a Hotel Room?
Chanukah- Shehechiyanu on the Second Night
Hanukah: Lighting When Traveling
Reciting Hallel on Hanukah
Hanukah – Lighting Candles After Minha in an Office; Lighting at Weddings or Other Public Gatherings
Hanukah – Lighting One Hanukah Candle From Another
2 Halachot: Lighting the Hanukah Candles on Friday Night and Where Does One Light the Hanukah Candles if He Goes Away for Shabbat?
The Importance of Lighting Hanukah Candles at the Proper Time
Reciting the Berachot Before Hanukah Candle Lighting; Customs for After Candle Lighting; Positioning the Candles
Hanukah: Do the Ashkenazim Follow the Rambam (How many Menorahs In Each Home by The Ashkenazim)?
Hanukah Candle Lighting in the Synagogue: How Many People Must be Present, and Which Berachot are Recited?
Hanukah Candles – Lighting in the Synagogue
Chanukah – Lighting When Staying Overnight With Parents, or During Overnight Travel
The Proper Time for Lighting Hanukah Candles; Eating and Learning Before Lighting the Hanukah Candles
The Reward for Lighting Hanukah Candles
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found