DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is In Memory of
 Beatrice Gindi, Batya bat Mazal

Dedicated By
Her family

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 10.9 MB)
If a Flagrant Shabbat Transgressor Handles Wine

The Shulhan Arukh (Yoreh De’ah 124:8) writes that if a "mumar" has contact with wine, the wine is prohibited to drink. In this context, a mumar is a Jew who has converted to another religion. What is the scope of this stringency?

The Rabbis teach us that one who violates Shabbat publically (mehalel Shabbat befarhesya) is considered to be a "mumar" (see Eruvin 67a), and is even compared to one who worships avoda zara (see Rashi, Bamidbar 15:41). Does that mean that wine which is touched by a mehalel Shabbat is prohibited?

Although in the Beit Yosef (Yoreh De’ah 119) he cites those who prohibit the wine, Maran does not bring this law in the Shulhan Arukh. Seemingly, the mehalel Shabbat himself is not literally worshipping avoda zara, and therefore this prohibition should not apply to him. Furthermore, one of the reasons for the decree prohibiting wine which was touch by non-Jews was to discourage intermarriage. It seems, however, that the prohibition of intermarriage does not apply to the Jew who is mehalel Shabbat.

There are Poskim (see, for example, Nekudot HaKesef 124), however, who write that wine touched by a mehalel Shabbat is prohibited. The Hatam Sofer (Yoreh De’ah 120) explains that although the wine of a mehalel Shabbat cannot be prohibited due to the fear of intermarriage, the Rabbis added a "kenas," a penalty, to those who flagrantly violate the Shabbat, including them in this law. R. Moshe Feinstein, in his Iggerot Moshe (Orah Haim 5:37), writes that this practice does not appear in the Talmud or the Shulhan Arukh, and is a minhag (custom).

Therefore, in practice, if we are hosting a non-religious Jew, we should be care that he should not touch our wine (i.e. wine which is not mevushal).

Some ask whether we may even give him wine to drink, as he should seemingly prohibit his own wine?! While some suggest that this is not considered to be lifnei iver (enabling a person to sin) since he can take the wine by himself, it may be simpler to explain that since the custom was enacted in order to discourage close, social contact, the person certainly cannot avoid close contact with himself! And therefore this prohibition would not apply to him.

Finally, we should note that this only applies to those mehalalie Shabbat who were raised with the awareness and knowledge of Shabbat, and chose to reject it. Furthermore, the Mishna Berura writes that one who violates the Shabbat, but is embarrassed in front of important people, is not considered to be a mehalel Shabbat befarhesya, and therefore his wine would be permitted.


 


Recent Daily Halachot...
What is the Proper Procedure For Making Up a Missed Reading of Shenayim Mikra Ve’ehad Targum?
How Should One Respond After Dreaming That He Committed a Sin?
The Obligation to Visit and Keep in Touch With One’s Parents
Hashkaba for an Infant; Which Name to Use When Reciting the Hashkaba Prayer
The Prohibition of Stealing From a Non-Jew, and Stealing Small Amounts of Money
Alenu – Pausing Before the Words “Va’anahnu Kor’im”
Seniut – Restrictions on Interaction Between Men and Women
Who Bears Liability When a Car Hits the Car In Front That Had Stopped Short?
Must One Stand When an Elderly Person Passes Near Him During Tefila?
The Proper Sequence When Listing the Names of the Matriarchs
Structures and Images That One May Not Make or Keep in the Home
Rosh Hashanah – Covering the Shofar While Reciting the Berachot
Must One Recite Birkat Ha’Torah Before Reading Biblical Verses as Prayer?
The Status of Wine That Was Looked at by an Idolater
The Sin of Mishkav Zachur (Homosexuality)
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found