DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is In Memory of
 Nathan Mizrachi
"L’iluy nishmat Natan ben Shoshana Levy"

Dedicated By
Dorit Mizrachi

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 2.04 MB)
Answering Kadish and Amen During Pesukeh D'zimra

The following Halachot were taught by Rav Gideon Ben Moshe regarding interrupting Tefila during Pesukeh D’zimra, from after Baruch She’amar until the end of Az Yashir. It is permitted to answer Barchu and at least the first five Amens of a Kadish, until "Da’amiran B’alma." It is also permitted to answer Amen to someone’s Berachot, such as the Beracha on Talit or Tefilin, or the Hazan’s Beracha at the end of Baruch She’amar.

The Halacha becomes more complex regarding answering while in the middle of Baruch She’amar. During the first half, there is no problem whatsoever, as it is merely verse of praise without a Beracha. There, one can answer anything- even the last Amens of Kadish, or "Baruch Hu U’varuch Shemo," which cannot be answered during the rest of Pesukeh D’zimra. However, during the second half of Baruch She’amar, which is actually one long Beracha, the Halacha is strict and prohibits interrupting to answer Amen to Berachot. For example, if the Hazan reaches the end before one completes the Beracha, he should not answer Amen to the Hazan’s Beracha. One can only answer Devarim She’bikdusha-such as Barchu and Kedusha, which require a Minyan to recite. These Halachot are commonly known and are recorded in the charts at the back of the Siddurim.

However, Rav Gideon Ben Moshe added that the conventional understanding regarding interrupting during Yishtabach is flawed. Yishtabach is not an independent Beracha; it is a "Beracha Semucha L’haverta"-adjoined to Baruch She’amar. Therefore, the entire Yishtabach is one long Beracha from beginning to end, and it has the status of the second half of Baruch She’amar, and Amen may not be answered. According to Rav Ben Moshe, some Siddurim and the Halacha Berura, mistakenly understood that one can answer Amen during Yishtabach, based on a misreading of the Ben Ish Hai who compared Yishtabach to Baruch She’amar.


 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Opening New Bottles on Shabbat
Meals on Erev Shabbat
Sending Mail Before Shabbat
Practical Applications of the Shabbat Prohibition of "Me'abeid"
Removing Dirt from a Garment on Shabbat
May a Man Wear a Ring in a Public Domain on Shabbat?
Is It Permissible On Shabbat To Visit A House Under Construction Or Renovation
Is It Permissible On Shabbat To Wear 2 Of the Same Garments Such As 2 Belts
Is It Permissible On Shabbat To Go To A Bus or Train Terminal With Plans On Getting On The Bus or Train After Shabbat
Walking in a Public Domain on Shabbat With Pebbles or Sand in One's Shoes
Tosefet Shabbat: Accepting Shabbat Several Minutes Before Sunset
The Woman's Obligation to Light the Shabbat Candles
May a Woman Walk in a Public Domain on Shabbat With a "Moch Dachuk"?
The Prohibition of "Tzad" (Trapping) on Shabbat -It Permissible To Lock A Child In A Room On Shabbat
Talking or Thinking About One's Business on Shabbat
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found