DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.13 MB)
Berachot after Changing Locations- Part 1

Shinui Makom, changing one’s location while eating, has a significant impact on the laws of Berachot. The Halacha depends on several variables, including the degree of change in place and the type of food eaten.

Regarding the food, the Gemara in Pesahim presents a Machloket between Rav Sheshat and Rav Hisdah. Rav Sheshat holds that leaving the original location of eating, requires a new Beracha when he returns. He does not differentiate between bread and other foods. Rav Hisdah argues that if one eats bread, he is always connected to his original place, since he is required to come back to say Birkat Hamazon. Therefore, if he left and returned, he can continue eating without a Beracha. With other foods, that do not require reciting a Beracha Achrona in the original location, leaving the place severs the ties to the original Beracha, and he must recite a new Beracha if he comes back and wants to continue eating.

Rambam and the Shulhan Aruch rule in accordance with Rav Sheshat; Even if one ate bread, leaving his place requires a new Beracha when he returns. The Rosh and the Rema rule in accordance with Rav Hisdah that leaving the place where he ate bread does not sever the connection to the original Beracha.

Even though Maran ruled on this matter, it is still considered a "Safek Berachot"-an uncertainty in the laws of Berachot, since there is a chain of disagreement from the Gemara through the Rishonim up until the Poskim. Therefore, the Halacha is to be lenient in a case of doubt and refrain from making a new Beracha of Hamosi if one left his place while eating bread. The best practice is to avoid entering this problematic situation in the first place by not leaving the place of eating bread. That way, there is no uncertainty at all.

If a person ate fruit, by himself, and then left his house, there is no disagreement. All agree that he must make a new Beracha of Ha’etz when he returns and wants to continue eating. He makes one Beracha Achrona at the end to cover both segments of eating.

SUMMARY
When eating bread, one should avoid leaving his place in the middle, if he intends to return and continue eating. If he did leave, he should not say a new Beracha of Hamosi when he returns to continue eating. When eating fruit by himself, one must recite a new Beracha if he leaves his place and then returns to continue eating.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
The Beracha Over Puffed Wheat and Granola Bars
Situations When One Does Not Recite a Beracha Before Drinking Water
Does One Recite “Ha’mosi” over Sweet Bread, or over So-Called “Mezonot Rolls”?
What Beracha Does One Recite on Pita Chips?
Which Beracha Does One Recite Over Pizza or Calzone?
What Must the Third Person Eat for Three People to Make a Zimun?
Reciting a Zimun if a Third Person Arrives After the First Two Finished Eating
Making a Zimun in a Moving Vehicle, Boat or Plane
Zimun If Ten People Ate Together But Not All of Them Ate Bread
Insight Into the Text of the Zimun
Can Three People Make a Zimun if One of Them Did Not Eat Bread?
Can a Minor be Counted Toward a Zimun?
Zimun in a Yeshiva Cafeteria
The Beracha Recited Over Chocolate Bars with Nuts, and Over Coated Almonds
Berachot If One Falls Asleep During A Meal
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found