DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is In Memory of
 Moshe ben Ya'acov v'Shoshana Sueke, Henri Sueke

Dedicated By
His loving family

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 874 KB)
Is It Permissible to Trap a Bug on Shabbat?

The Rema in Siman 316 brings down the Halacha that it is prohibited to close a box or container in which there is a bug. Doing so constitutes the Melacha of Saad (trapping). This holds true even if the bug is not the type which is usually trapped, and the violation is only D’rabanan (rabbinic).

Interestingly, Maran does not bring this Halacha in Shulhan Aruch. This is especially puzzling since he does present this Halacha in his Bet Yosef, in the name of its source, the Sefer HaTerumah, and comments "Mi Yakel K’negdo?"-Who can be lenient against his ruling?

The Poskim explain why Maran didn’t bring this Halacha in Shulhan Aruch based on a general Halachic principle of Maran. In this case, the person closing the box does not intend to trap the bug; he just wants the box closed and the bug becomes trapped unintentionally, albeit inevitably. This is known as "Pesik Reshe D’lo Nicha Leh"-an action whose inevitable outcome is a Melacha, but that outcome was not the purpose of the action and the person has no interest or benefit from that outcome. Hacham Ovadia (Yabia Omer 4:15, Ohr Yisrael p. 92) holds that Maran’s position on such cases was to be lenient when the Melacha involved is M’drabanan (rabbinic). This could explain why Maran didn’t bring this prohibition, since the Melacha involved is only M’drabanan, as the case is referring to bugs that are not usually trapped. It goes without saying that if one is not sure whether there is even a bug in the box to begin with, there is no problem closing the box.

SUMMARY
One may close a box containing a type of bug that is not usually trapped, if his intent is merely to seal the box and not to trap the bug.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Different Interpretations to the Beracha of "Retzei" in the Amida
Remaining in One's Place After Reciting Oseh Shalom
Reciting the Verse "Potei'ach Et Yadecha" with Concentration
Should One Bow In The Amidah If Praying In Public In Front Of A Gentile Who Is Wearing Religious Items
Baruch Sheamar
An Understanding of the 18 Birchot Hashachar and The Times It May Be Said
May A Chazan Begin Chazara If He Was Unable To Take 3 Step Back In His Silent Amidah
Walking In Front of A Person Who Is Reciting The Amidah
Is One Required To Stand During Kaddish
May A Person Answer Amen To A Kaddish While He Personally Is Saying A Negative Statement
Guidelines for One Who Forgot to Recite Mashiv Ha'ru'ach in the Amidah
The Beracha of "She'asa Li Kol Tzorki"
Birchot HaShachar- The Beracha of Lihavcheen Ben Yom Uben Lilah
May One Answer "Amen" After Reciting "Yiheyu Le'ratzon" at the End of the Amida?
The Proper Pronunciation of Hebrew Letters During Keri'at Shema
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found