DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.47 MB)
Opening Vessels on Shabbat: Soda Cans, Yogurt Cups and Bottles

The Poskim discuss whether one may open a soda can on Shabbat. This Halacha is contingent on Maran ruling (314:1) that it is prohibited to make a "nice opening" in a vessel. Doing so is considered "Metaken Manah"-fixing a vessel. One may might assume that puncturing the opening of the can also forms a nice, smooth opening, and should therefore be prohibited. Nevertheless, the Poskim, including Hacham Ovadia and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach (Jerusalem, 1910-1995), say that Maran was only referring to vessels which will be used repeatedly in the future. When opening a soda can, one merely wants to remove the liquid, and has no intention of fixing the vessel for further use. Therefore, it is permitted to open a soda can, and there is no problem of "Metaken Manah."

The Menuhat Ahaba (Rabbi Moshe Halevy, Israel, 1961-2001) writes a Chidush that it is problematic to drink directly from the can, because it is considered that the vessel itself was fixed and rendered a temporary cup. Hacham Ovadia (Hazon Ovadia, Vol. 5, p. 384) rejects this approach and permits drinking directly. Rav Shlomo Zalman was also lenient on this issue.

----

The Poskim also discuss whether it is permitted to separate yogurt cups that are attached together. The Menuhat Ahaba, is strict, basing himself on Rambam, whereas Hacham Ovadia and Rav Shlomo Zalman are lenient. Hacham Ovadia (Halichot Olam 4:254) argues that each cup is distinct and is designed to be separated; thus, there is no similarity to the case of Rambam. Hacham Bension is also lenient (Or Lesion 27:7) comparing this case to the Gemara's case of "Hotlot Shel Temarim"- a reed basket, which may be ripped open. This flimsy type of packaging is considered nothing more than a shell which wraps the nut.

Similarly, it is permitted to rip open a potato chip bag and the like. It would also be permitted to separate tea bags which are attached to each other. There is no violation of "Mehatech" (ripping) because there is no intent to rip according to a specific measure, and therefore that prohibition does not apply. However, there may be an issue of the Melacha of Koreah, and therefore, some Poskim say that it should be ripped with a Shinui (unusual method).

----

There is an issue of opening a bottle which has a cap attached by a ring. When the cap is twisted, the ring separates and falls to the neck of the bottle. This may constitute a violation of Shabbat, since the act of twisting the cap now enables the cap to function as such. Before, it was a seal of the bottle, and now it is a separate vessel. Rav Shlomo Zalman distinguishes between metal and plastic bottle tops. The metal caps have a ring which is an integral part of it, attached by perforation. Twisting it open creates a new entity. The plastic ones are not a part of the cap itself, and do not constitute a problem. Some Poskim, such as the Menuhat Ahaba, say that neither variety is problematic, since it was always considered a cap. However, he rules that it should not be used to cover a different bottle, since that is already a new function.

SUMMARY
It is permissible to open a soda can on Shabbat and drink from it.
It is permissible to separate attached yogurt cups and freeze pops.
It is permissible to open bottle tops attached with a ring, although it is recommended to open them before Shabbat, especially the metal type.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Hanukah – One Who Cannot Afford Enough Oil for the Hanukah Candles
Hanukah – Eulogies, Fasting and Visiting Cemeteries During Hanukah
The Beracha Recited Before and After One Eats a Jelly Donut; Placing a Jelly Donut on a Hot Plate on Shabbat
Chanukah- Where Should the Menorah in the Synagogue be Positioned
Chanukah- Should One Continue To Light If He Missed Lighting The Night Before
The Custom to Eat Cheese on Hanukah; Reciting a Beracha When Eating Cheese on a Cracker
Chanukah- Guidelines Concerning Situations Where a Congregation Read the Wrong Selection from the Torah During Chanukah
Chanukah- Warming Fried Jelly Doughnuts on Shabbat & A Mourner's Participation in Chanukah Celebrations
Chanukah- In The Event You Forgot Sh’hecheyanu The First Night
Chanukah- Do We Repeat All 3 Berachot When Lighting In The Synagogue On The First Night of Chanukah?
Chanukah- When Is It Permissible To Recite Hallel
Mincha Erev Shabbat When The First Night of Chanukah Occurs on Friday Night
Chanukah- Should One Light When In A Place Full of Goyim Even If His Wife Lights In His Stead At Home
For How Long Must the Chanukah Candles Burn in the Synagogue?
Chanukah- Should One Still Recite She'hecheyanu If Lighting After A Person Lit In His Stead On The First Night
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found