DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.08 MB)
Amira L'Akum- Instructing a Non-Jew to Perform Less Than the Minimum Measure of a Melacha

The Halacha permits Shvut D'shvut, instructing a non-Jew to perform a Melacha on Shabbat that is only prohibited M'drabanan (from Rabbinic law), for the sake of a Misva, a sick person or to avoid a major financial loss.
Generally, the prohibitions in the Torah have a minimal measure which must be violated in order to be culpable. For example, one is not culpable for eating forbidden foods until he eats a Kesayit-an olive bulk. There is a discussion as to the status of violating "Hasi Shiur"-less than the minimal measure. While all agree that it is prohibited to do so, the question is whether such a violation is prohibited from the Torah or M'drabanan. If it is prohibited from the Torah, the difference between less and more than the minimum is whether the perpetrator is liable to receive Malkot (lashes).

This Rambam, in his introduction to Hilchot Shabbat, states that performing less than the minimal amount of a Melacha on Shabbat is only liable M'drabanan. For example, the minimum amount of writing deemed a Melacha from the Torah is writing two letters. If one wrote only one letter, he is only liable M'drabanan. Hacham Bension brought a proof to this position from the Tossefta.

This principle is relevant to defining a Shvut D'shvut to instruct a non-Jew to perform a Melacha M'drabanan. For example, if someone is sick with a non-life threatening illness and requires a small quantity of medication to be pulverized, it is permitted to tell a non-Jew to pulverize the medicine less than the minimum measurement. Although pulverising is a Melacha D'oraita, pulverising such a small amount is only prohibited M'drabanan, and therefore, this qualifies as a Shvut D'shvut in a case of sickness.

Another example would be telling a non-Jew to sign a pharmacy receipt in order to provide medicine to someone sick with a non-life threatening illness. If he only signs with a one letter initial, it is less than the minimum measure to constitute a Melacha D'oraita. Therefore, it is permitted to tell him to do so.

SUMMARY
Performing less than the prescribed measure of a Melacha on Shabbat is only prohibited M'drabanan. Therefore, it is permitted to instruct a non-Jew to do such an amount for the sake of a Misva, a sick person or to prevent major financial loss.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Passover- The Proper Procedures for ERUV TAVSHILIN When Yom Tov Is On Thursday and Friday
Pesah- When & How To Conduct Bedikat Hames
The Pesah Seder – Using a Seder Plate, Kissing the Masa, the Procedure For Pouring Out Wine While Listing the Ten Plagues
Laws and Customs of the Seder
The Significance of Shabbat Hagadol
Pesah – Eating “Gebrukst” (Masa with liquid), and the Requirement of “Masa Shemura”
Pesah – Making a Thorough Search Even Though the House Was Already Cleaned
Pesah – Explaining the Requirements of Bittul Hametz and Bedikat Hametz
Pesah: Bananas, Quinoa and Mustard
Do Tablets, Cosmetics, Soaps, Shampoos and Detergents Require “Kosher for Pesah” Certification?
Pesah- The Procedure for Kashering Stove Grates, Oven Racks, Blechs, and Tablecloths
Pesah- Koshering Cookware in Preparation for Pesah
Pesah- Baby Bottles, Barbeques, Birkat Ha’mazon Cards, Cookbooks, Microwaves, Nutcrackers and Salt Shakers
Pesah- Koshering Garlic Presses, Highchairs and Kitchen Counters
Pesah- Koshering the Dishwasher, Oven, Tables, Countertops, Microwave, Stovetop, and Sink
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found