DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.21 MB)
Amira L’Akum-If a Non-Jew Turned On a Light for his Own Benefit

If a non-Jew performed Melacha specifically for a Jew, all Jews are subsequently prohibited from benefiting from that Melacha on Shabbat. However, the Shulhan Aruch in Siman 276 rules that if the non-Jew did the Melacha for his own use, the Jew may benefit from it on Shabbat. For example, if the Jew is sitting in a dark room, unable to read, and the non-Jew enters the room looking for some item of his and turns on the lights to aid his search, the Jew may read with that light.

What would be the Halacha if, in such a case, the non-Jew wants to turn off the lights after locating his item? Is the Jew allowed to ask him to refrain from extinguishing the lights, in order that he continue to benefit. The Poskim rule that it is permitted to do so, since the Jew is not instructing the non-Jew to actively perform a Melacha . All he is doing is asking him to refrain passively, "Shev V’al Ta’aseh."

This case illustrates a general principle by which any time the lights were turned on in permitted circumstances, all other Jews may continue to benefit afterwards.

One application of this principle would be if a non-Jew turned on the lights for a "Choleh She’en Bo Sakanah" (A person sick with a non-life-threatening-illness) or a "Katan" (child). In both instances, not only may the patient or child benefit from the light, but so may anyone else. For that matter, even if the light was turned on by Jews, such as in a case where Hatzolah was called to tend to a life-threatening emergency in a dark home on Friday night, other people may continue to benefit from the light.

It is important to stress that these Halachot have many variations and details. Each case is unique, and the layman cannot extrapolate from case to another.

SUMMARY
If a non-Jew turned on the light for his own benefit, a Jew may benefit from it.
In such a case, the Jew may ask the non-Jew to refrain from turning the lights back off.
Any case in which it was permitted to turn on the lights, anyone may benefit from the light.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Is it Permissible to Erase a Recording of a Torah Class?
The Ancient Syrian Jewish Customs For Mosa’eh Shabbat Shira and Tu B’Shbat
Should the Tefillin be Worn During Minha When Asara Be'Tebet Falls on Ereb Shabbat
Mr. Edmond J Safra A”H – Supporter of the Three Pillars - Yahrtzeit Today
Shinui Makom – If a Person Leaves His Home During a Meal Momentarily
The Obligation to Visit One’s Parents
Is It Permissible For A Kohen To Travel Over A Cemetery In A Plane
Having Intention for the Misva Before Reciting Shema
The Custom to Perform Hatarat Nedarim Before the Month of Elul
Halachot Pertaining to the Restroom
The Five Groups of "Minim" Who Have No Share in the World to Come
The Significance of Visiting Graves of Sadikim
Visiting the Graves of Sadikim and Family Members
May One Use a Pot Cover for Netilat Yadayim?
The Symbolism of the Five Knots of the Sisit
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found