DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is In Memory of
  David Ben Baba Kavian

Dedicated By
Mikael Kavian

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 778 KB)
Hiring a Jew Who Has Not Recited Habdala Since the Previous Shabbat

Halacha forbids performing Melacha (activity forbidden on Shabbat) on Saturday night, even after Shabbat has concluded, until one has made a verbal declaration formally ending the Shabbat observance. Meaning, one may not perform Melacha on Mosa’eh Shabbat until he recites Habdala, recites the words, "Baruch Ha’mabdil Ben Kodesh Le’hol," or recites "Ata Honantanu" in Arbit. A person who did not make any such recitation is forbidden from doing Melacha through Tuesday. The prohibition does not extend into Wednesday, since at that point the week becomes associated with the coming Shabbat, as opposed to the previous Shabbat.

An interesting question arises as to whether one may hire the services of a non-observant Jew who presumably has not recited Habdala (or the other recitations mentioned above) since the previous Shabbat. For example, may a person hire a non-observant taxi driver to drive him somewhere on Mosa’eh Shabbat, Sunday, Monday or Tuesday? Seemingly, since it is forbidden for the driver to perform Melacha through Tuesday, it would be forbidden to hire him to perform Melacha on one’s behalf. For that matter, may an employer hire a Jewish worker who does not observe Shabbat and thus, in all likelihood, does not recite Habdala, and is therefore forbidden from performing Melacha from Mosa’eh Shabbat through Tuesday?

This question was addressed by Rabbi Eliezer Waldenberg (Israel, 1915-2006), in his work Sitz Eliezer. He cites some authorities who advise a person in this situation to extend the wish of "Shabua Tob" ("Have a good week") to the non-observant Jew, so that he will then respond, "Shabua Tob." This response, according to some views, qualifies as a formal declaration of the end of Shabbat, and thus suffices to permit one to perform Melacha. Thus, for example, a person who takes a taxi driven by a non-observant Jew should wish the driver "Shabua Tob" before entering the car, so that the driver will respond and then be allowed to perform Melacha.

Rav Waldenberg himself, however, disagrees with this view, noting that the "Shabua Tov" greeting does not relate in any way to the theme of Habdala, the distinction between Shabbat and the weekday. In his view, wishing somebody "Have a good week" does not suffice to permit one to perform Melacha.

After a lengthy and thorough analysis of this issue, Rabbi Waldenberg concludes that it is permissible to hire a non-observant Jew who did not recite Habdala, though for an entirely different reason. Rabbi Waldenberg establishes that the prohibition against performing Melacha before reciting Habdala applies only to somebody who intends to recite Habdala. If a person does not observe the Misvot and therefore does not plan on reciting Habdala, then although he is certainly guilty of neglecting a Misva, he is not bound by the prohibition against performing Melacha after Shabbat. Since he does not anticipate reciting Habdala, his failure to do so has no effect upon his status with respect to Melacha after Shabbat. Rav Waldenberg draws an analogy to the prohibition against eating in the morning before reciting Shaharit. Despite this prohibition, it is permissible to serve breakfast to a non-observant Jew who can be presumed not to have prayed Shaharit that morning. Since the non-observant Jew has no intention of praying Shaharit, the prohibition against eating before praying does not pertain to him. Similarly, Rav Waldenberg asserts, a person who does not plan on reciting Habdala is not included in the prohibition against performing Melacha before Habdala, and one may therefore hire his services even though he has not recited Habdala.

Summary: Although one may not perform Melacha after Shabbat before he recites Habdala (or some other formal declaration of the end of Shabbat), it is permissible to hire the services of a non-observant Jew, even though he can be presumed not to have recited Habdala.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Different Interpretations to the Beracha of "Retzei" in the Amida
Remaining in One's Place After Reciting Oseh Shalom
Reciting the Verse "Potei'ach Et Yadecha" with Concentration
Should One Bow In The Amidah If Praying In Public In Front Of A Gentile Who Is Wearing Religious Items
Baruch Sheamar
An Understanding of the 18 Birchot Hashachar and The Times It May Be Said
May A Chazan Begin Chazara If He Was Unable To Take 3 Step Back In His Silent Amidah
Walking In Front of A Person Who Is Reciting The Amidah
Is One Required To Stand During Kaddish
May A Person Answer Amen To A Kaddish While He Personally Is Saying A Negative Statement
Guidelines for One Who Forgot to Recite Mashiv Ha'ru'ach in the Amidah
The Beracha of "She'asa Li Kol Tzorki"
Birchot HaShachar- The Beracha of Lihavcheen Ben Yom Uben Lilah
May One Answer "Amen" After Reciting "Yiheyu Le'ratzon" at the End of the Amida?
The Proper Pronunciation of Hebrew Letters During Keri'at Shema
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found