DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.03 MB)
Purim – If the Megilla is Missing Some Words

The Megilla must be read from a parchment scroll, and those listening to the reading from a parchment scroll fulfill their obligation through their listening, even though they do not have a parchment scroll in front of them. If a person does not hear a word or several words of the Megilla, he should say those words and quickly catch up to the reader. As long as he hears the rest of the Megilla, he fulfills his obligation by reading the words which he missed. By the same token, if the reader notices that the Megilla he is using is missing several words, he may read those words from memory, and then both he and the listeners fulfill their obligation. Although the entire Megilla should be read from a parchment scroll, one nevertheless fulfills his obligation if he reads some of the Megilla from memory, as long as most of the Megilla was read from a scroll. As opposed to a Sefer Torah, which is invalid for use if it is missing even a single letter, a Megilla is valid even if it is missing some words, as long as the majority of the text is written. Therefore, if the reader knows from memory the missing words, he may say them from memory and his reading is then valid.

There is, however, one exception to this rule. The Rama (Rav Moshe Isserles of Cracow, 1525-1572) writes that if the first verse of the Megilla – "Va’yehi Bi’ymeh Ahashverosh" – or the last verse of the Megilla – "Ki Mordechai Ha’yehudi" – is missing, then the reading is not valid. Even though the reader knows the missing words by heart and says them correctly, the reading is invalid. However, Hacham Ovadia Yosef (Hazon Ovadia – Purim, p. 255) rules that this exception does not apply in the case where someone in the congregation did not hear the first or last Pasuk. In such a case, the person can read the words he missed from his text or from memory, just as he can if he missed any other words from the Megila. It is only if the first or last Pasuk is missing from the Megilla that the reading is invalid, because such a Megilla is not suitable for the Misva. But if somebody who is listening to the reading does not hear the first or last Pasuk, and he reads the missed words on his own, he has certainly fulfilled the Misva.

Summary: If a person listening to the Megilla does not hear several words, he should read those words from his text and thereby fulfills the Misva. Likewise, if the reader notices that some words are missing from his Megilla, he can say them from memory and he and his listeners fulfill the obligation. If, however, the Megilla is missing the first or last Pasuk, then the Megilla is disqualified for use.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
The Beracha Over Puffed Wheat and Granola Bars
Situations When One Does Not Recite a Beracha Before Drinking Water
Does One Recite “Ha’mosi” over Sweet Bread, or over So-Called “Mezonot Rolls”?
What Beracha Does One Recite on Pita Chips?
Which Beracha Does One Recite Over Pizza or Calzone?
What Must the Third Person Eat for Three People to Make a Zimun?
Reciting a Zimun if a Third Person Arrives After the First Two Finished Eating
Making a Zimun in a Moving Vehicle, Boat or Plane
Zimun If Ten People Ate Together But Not All of Them Ate Bread
Insight Into the Text of the Zimun
Can Three People Make a Zimun if One of Them Did Not Eat Bread?
Can a Minor be Counted Toward a Zimun?
Zimun in a Yeshiva Cafeteria
The Beracha Recited Over Chocolate Bars with Nuts, and Over Coated Almonds
Berachot If One Falls Asleep During A Meal
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found