DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.13 MB)
Changing Places Within the Same Room During a Meal

One of the especially intricate and complex areas of Halacha is that of "Shinui Makom" – changing one’s location in the middle of a meal – which the Shulhan Aruch discusses in Orah Haim 178. Many different variables will determine when it is permissible to leave one’s place before reciting a Beracha Aharona or Birkat Ha’mazon, and whether one must recite a new Beracha when he resumes eating in his new location, or when he returns to his original location.

Here, we present one very straightforward Halacha which is agreed upon by all Halachic authorities, namely, one may change places within the same room in the middle of a meal. As long as one does not leave the room, he may change locations and then resume eating in his new location without reciting a new Beracha. For example, if in a synagogue or study hall there is a coffee machine in the back of the room, one may make his coffee, recite the Beracha and begin drinking in the back of the room, and then bring it to the front of the room and continue drinking there without reciting a new Beracha. This applies even if one changes locations within a very large room, like a banquet hall, and cannot see his original location because it is obstructed by furniture, a pillar, a vase, or some other object. At weddings, for example, if often happens that a person begins eating in one location, and then sees a friend at a different table and moves next to him. This is entirely permissible, and he does not have to recite a new Beracha when he resumes eating at his new location, since he moved within the same room. This is permissible even if one had no intention when he began eating that he would later change locations.

This Halacha is discussed by Hacham David Yosef, in Halacha Berura (vol. 9, p. 203; listen to audio recording for precise citation).

Summary: One may change locations within the same room during a meal, even if he cannot see his original seat in his new location, and even if he did not intend to move when he began eating, and he does not need to recite a new Beracha when he resumes eating at his new location.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Yichud- Is It Permissible For A Man To Be In A Classroom Full of Women
Yichud- Does The Leniency of Ba’Ala Ba’Ir For Women Also Apply For Man
Yichud- A Close Bond Negates The Leniency Of Ba'Ala Ba'Ir
Yichud- Does the Leniency of Ba’Ala BaIr Even Apply When The Husband Is At Work
Yichud- Can A Married Woman Be Secluded With A Man Outside of The Home
Yichud- Can One Woman Be Secluded With More Than One Man Such As House Workers (Plumber)
Yichud- Does The Prohibition of Seclusion Apply To Married Couples When The When The Wife is Needah
The Concept of Yichud- The Prohibition Of Being Alone With Others
The Prohibition Against Lending and Borrowing on Interest; Collecting a Debt if the Loan Was Given on Interest
To Whom Should One Lend Money To When Many Seek A Loan
The Misva to Lend Money
Must One Understand the Words of Kiddush to Fulfill His Obligation?
Waking One’s Parents; Relaying Distressing News to One’s Parents
The Value of Arising Early in the Morning and Staying Up Late at Night
Committing a Transgression in Order to Prevent Another Person From Sinning
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found