DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 642 KB)
Standing for the Recitation of Shema

Is it proper to stand while reciting Shema?

The Talmud in Masechet Berachot 10B records a debate between Beit Hillel (the school of the scholar Hillel) and Beit Shammai (the school of the scholar Shammai) concerning the Torah's requirement that one recite Shema "Be'shochbecha U've'kumecha" ("as you lie down and as you rise"). Beit Hillel understood this verse as a reference to the proper time for this recitation: one must read the Shema in the evening, when people normally lie down, and in the morning, when people generally rise from their beds. Beit Shammai, by contrast, interpreted this phrase as establishing the required position during the recitation of Shema: in the evening, one must lie down while reciting Shema, and in the morning, one must recite Shema while standing. It thus emerges that according to Beit Hillel, the Torah imposes no requirements concerning the proper position while reciting Shema, whereas Beit Shammai requires standing for the daytime Shema and reclining for the nighttime Shema.

Halacha, of course, follows the view of Beit Hillel, that one fulfills his obligation regardless of the position in which he recites Shema (Shulchan Aruch 63:1). The Shulchan Aruch (63:2) writes that a person who makes a point to follow Beit Shammai's stringency, and rises from his seat for the recitation of the morning Shema, is considered an "Avaryan" – a sinner – for opposing the accepting view of Beit Hillel. The Mishna Berura (commentary to the Shulchan Aruch by Rabbi Yisrael Meir Kagan, the "Chafetz Chayim," Lithuania, 1835-1933) (ibid Seif kattan 5) extends this rule to a case of one who stands not for the purpose of satisfying Beit Shammai's position, but rather to enhance his concentration. Even though he does not stand with the intention of following Beit Shammai's view, such a person acts improperly by appearing to reject the accepted position of Beit Hillel. Nevertheless, as the Mishna Berura cites from the Peri Megadim (Halachic work by Rabbi Yosef Teomim, Germany, 1727-1792), if one did stand from his seat for the recitation of Shema, although he has acted improperly, he has nevertheless fulfilled his obligation and need not repeat the Shema. See Halacha Berura, Helek 4, page 361 that says in such a case, it is preferable to repeat the Sheam after the Tefilah.

Summary: It is preferable to sit while reciting Shema, and one should certainly not rise from his seat specifically for the Shema recitation, even if he feels that this would enhance his concentration. Nevertheless, if one did stand during the recitation of Shema, he has fulfilled his obligation and is not required to repeat the Shema, but he should preferably repeat the Shema after the Tefilah.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Is It Permissible to Spread a Talet Over the Children on Simhat Torah?
Is It Permissible On Shabbat To Walk On Grass Or To Have A Picnic On Grass
Reading Shir Hashirim on Ereb Shabbat
Peeling a Hardboiled Egg on Shabbat
Inflating a Ball on Shabbat
Is It Permissible To Repair Eye Glasses on Shabbat
Walking in a Public Domain on Shabbat With Food in One's Mouth
Asking a Gentile on Shabbat to Cut Tissue Paper; Asking a Gentile on Shabbat to Turn on a Light for a Frightened Child
Mukse- If a Base for a Mukse Item Also Holds a Non-Mukse Item
Mukse- Handling a Corpse on Shabbat
If Part of A Utensil or A Button Becomes Detached on Shabbat
Is It Permissible To Move Frozen Meat On Shabbat Or Is It Muktze
Mukse – the Status of Chicken Bones and Eggshells
Collecting Candies That Were Thrown in the Synagogue on Shabbat
Mukse: Placing Empty Shells on a Plate
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found