DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 588 KB)
Mukse – the Status of Chicken Bones and Eggshells

Objects that are not suitable for use by human beings, but are suitable for animals, do not have the status of Mukse on Shabbat, and thus may be handled. A common example of such an object is soft bones, such as chicken bones. Although people cannot make use of bones, they are suitable for dogs. Therefore, in a place where there are dogs, chicken bones do not have a status of Mukse, and may be handled on Shabbat.

However, an object that can be used by neither people nor animals does, indeed, have the status of Mukse. A common example of this kind of item is an eggshell, which has no value to humans or animals, and is therefore consider Mukse. In fact, Rav Haim Palachi (Turkey, 1788-1869) held that it is forbidden to peel a boiled egg on Shabbat, unless one does so in a manner that does not require handling the pieces of shell, meaning, the egg comes out of shell, rather than pieces of shell being removed. Hacham Ovadia Yosef disputes this ruling, noting that there is no indication in the Talmud or later authorities that peeling an egg is forbidden on Shabbat. Certainly, however, after an egg is peeled, the shells have the status of Mukse and may not be handled. It is therefore advisable to peel an egg directly over a garbage can. If one peels an egg over a counter, for example, and the shells fall onto the counter, it would be forbidden to remove them from the counter until after Shabbat.

Another concern involving eggshells is the prohibition against rendering a functional utensil Mukse on Shabbat. If one peels an egg over an empty utensil, such as a bowl or dish, the utensil becomes Mukse by virtue of its serving as a "base" for a Mukse object. Halacha forbids rendering a usable item Mukse on Shabbat, and it is therefore forbidden to peel an egg over an empty utensil on Shabbat. If one wishes to peel an egg over a utensil, he should first put some food into the utensil. This way, when the eggshells fall into the utensil, the utensil will be a "base" for both permissible and forbidden objects, and thus does not become Mukse. As mentioned, one can simply peel the egg over a trashcan, and thereby avoid all Mukse-related problems involving the shells.

Summary: Chicken bones are not considered Mukse on Shabbat, because they are suitable for dogs. Eggshells, however, are not usable for people or animals, and are therefore considered Mukse on Shabbat. One may peel an egg on Shabbat, but after peeling the egg he may not handle the eggshells. Furthermore, one may not peel an egg onto a functional utensil unless there is already something usable (such as food) in the utensil. It is advisable to peel boiled eggs directly over a trashcan, in order to avoid all Mukse-related problems.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
One Explanation for the Phrase “Sabri Maranan”
Trickery, Lying, and Deceiving, Are Forms of Stealing:"Geneivat Da'at" – Thievery Through Deception
Must a Convert Immerse All His Utensils After His Conversion?
May the Chazan Invite Somebody Else to Lead Birkat Kohanim in His Stead?
Is It Permissible To Stand or Sit With Your Back To The Hechal
May a Guest Refuse the Host's Invitation to Lead the Zimun?
The Power of Learning Mishnayot
Is It A Transgression To Simply Bypass A Request (Email) To Pray For Others In Need, and How To Properly Refer To One's Parents In A Blessing
May a Kohen Leave Israel?
Refusing an Aliya to the Torah
May a New Bride or Groom Attend Somebody Else’s Wedding?
Coming Late To A Reception, Unauthorized Acceptance and Collection of Valued Goods and Services
Pat Shacharit - Bread Of The Morning (Breakfast)
Reading Pirkeh Abot Between Pesah and Shabuot
Birkat Ha'ilanot – Reciting the Beracha with a Minyan, and Reciting the Beracha Upon the Second Sighting of Blossoming Trees
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found