DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 806 KB)
Eating Meat on a Table Containing Dairy Foods

It is forbidden for two acquaintances to eat at the same table if one eats meat and the other milk or dairy products. The Sages were concerned that the acquaintances might share each other’s food and thus violate the prohibition against partaking of meat with milk, and they therefore forbade eating meat at the same table where somebody partakes of milk, and vice versa. (See Shulhan Aruch, Yore De’a 88). Acquaintances may eat meat and milk at the same table only if they place on the table a "Heker," or some object that is not normally on the table (such as a vase), to remind them that they may not partake of each other’s food. If the table is long and the two acquaintances eat far enough from each other so that one cannot reach the other’s plate, then they may eat together at the same table, even without a "Heker."

The question arises as to whether these Halachot apply to a person who eats meat alone at a table containing dairy foods (or vice versa). In this case, there is no other person with whom he might share food, but on the other hand, we should perhaps still be concerned that he may mistakenly partake of the dairy foods.

Indeed, Halacha forbids eating meat alone at a table containing dairy foods (or vice versa), even if one places a "Heker." In the case of two acquaintances, placing a "Heker" allows them to eat together because they have two safeguards: the "Heker," and each other. Meaning, even if one of them overlooks the "Heker" and wishes to partake of the other’s food, the other person will likely stop him. In the case of a person eating alone, however, the "Heker" serves as his only safeguard, and this does not suffice to permit eating with dairy food on the table.

Hacham Ovadia Yosef added, however, that one may eat meat at a table containing dairy foods if another person is present. Even if that person does not eat anything, his presence suffices as the second "safeguard" which allows eating meat at a table containing dairy foods.

The Peri Megadim (work by Rabbi Yosef Teomim, 1727-1792) noted that this prohibition does not apply to a person who had eaten meat within the previous six hours. Even though such a person may not partake of dairy foods, he may eat Parve food at a table together with somebody eating dairy foods. The Peri Megadim maintains that the Sages did not go so far as to forbid eating at a table with dairy foods within six hours of eating meat. Likewise, it would be permissible for somebody to prepare a dairy dish within six hours of eating meat, provided, of course, that he ensures not to taste any of the dairy food.

Summary: One may not eat meat at the same table where an acquaintance eats dairy foods (or vice versa), unless they are seated beyond arm’s length from each other, or they place on the table an item that is not usually on the table. A person eating alone may not eat meat if dairy products are on the table (and vice versa), even if he places an object on the table. Within six hours of eating meat, one may not eat dairy foods, but he may eat Parve food at a table with an acquaintance eating dairy foods. One may prepare dairy dishes within six hours of eating meat.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Purim- Laws Regarding the Megila Scroll
Purim – Does One Add Al Ha'nisim in Birkat Ha'mazon if the Meal Ends After Dark?
Purim – Sending Mishlo'ah Manot to a Mourner
Purim – When is the Preferred Time for the Purim Meal?
Handling a Megila on Shabbat
Purim Katan: Haman's Decree and Kashrut
"Purim Katan" – the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Days of Adar Rishon
Purim- Is Megilat Esther Considered Muktze on Shabbat
Purim- Machatzit Ha'shekel
Purim- Reading Haman's 10 Son's Names In One Breath, and Is It Permissible TO Recite The Berachot on The Megila If Less Than A Minyan
Purim- When and How To Recite Havdala When Purim Falls Out On Motza’ei Shabbat
Purim- An Explanation and Understanding of the Page with 10 Names in Megilat Esther
Purim- Some Halachot When Taanit Esther Is Observed On Thursday Prior To Purim That Falls Out On Saturday Night
Is It Permissible for A Sofer To Use Silk Screening Process When Producing a Megilah or Sefer Torah
Purim- Certain Required Characteristics of A Kosher Megilah
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found