DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is For The Hatzlacha of
 Simon Abda
"Dedicated to the safe return of my good friend and brother Simon Abda. A viable asset to the entire community. You make everyone around you a better person and I'm lucky to call you a friend"

Dedicated By
Eddie Aziz

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 766 KB)
Allowing a Gentile to Voluntarily Perform a Melacha on Shabbat; Making an Indirect Request to a Gentile on Shabbat

Generally speaking, Halacha forbids instructing a gentile to perform Melacha (activity forbidden on Shabbat) on a Jew's behalf on Shabbat. Moreover, as noted by the Mishna Berura (commentary to the Shulhan Aruch by Rabbi Yisrael Kagan, 1839-1933) in Siman 276 (11), if a gentile voluntarily offers to perform a Melacha on a Jew's behalf, the Jew must object and instruct the gentile to desist. Even though the gentile acts voluntarily, and not at the Jew's behest, the Jew must nevertheless voice his objection since the gentile seeks to perform a Melacha on his behalf. (Needless to say, one need not stop a gentile from performing Melacha on Shabbat for his own purposes.) This applies even if the Jew has no intention of deriving any benefit from the action the gentile seeks to perform. If the gentile acts in order to do a service to the Jew, the Jew must object.

One common example of this Halacha arises when a non-Jewish housekeeper volunteers to turn on a light in a dark room for her Jewish employer. Not only does Halacha forbid instructing or asking her to turn on the light, it also requires the Jew to tell her not to turn on the light if she offers to do so. Similarly, if the gardener arrives on Shabbat to work on the lawn, one must instruct him not to do so. (Of course, one should clarify from the outset when hiring a gardener that no gardening work should be done on Shabbat or holidays.)

If a person sits in a dimly-lit room, where there is sufficient light for whichever activity he wishes to perform in that room (e.g. reading or eating), he may indirectly ask a gentile to turn on a light by indicating his desire for additional illumination. Thus, for example, if the lights are turned off but the sunlight from the windows provides enough light to read, one who wishes some additional light may say to his gentile housekeeper, "This room could use some more light." Although he may not explicitly request that she turn on the light, he may, in this situation, express his request indirectly. This is the ruling of several authorities, including the Hida (Rav Haim Yosef David Azulai, 1724-1806) in his Birke Yosef (307:6), the Ben Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909) in his Rav Pe'alim (Orah Haim 83), and Hacham Ovadia Yosef in Halichot Olam (vol. 3, p. 179).

If the room is dark, however, such that one cannot perform the desired activity in the room, then he may not ask a gentile even indirectly to turn on a light. Indirect requests are allowed only in cases where there is sufficient light and one seeks additional illumination.

Summary: One may not ask a gentile to perform Melacha on his (the Jew's) behalf on Shabbat, and if a gentile offers to do Melacha for a Jew, the Jew must object. If a dimly-lit room has sufficient light but one desires additional light, he may indirectly express a request to a gentile to turn on a light, but he may not ask directly.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Yichud- Is It Permissible For A Man To Be In A Classroom Full of Women
Yichud- Does The Leniency of Ba’Ala Ba’Ir For Women Also Apply For Man
Yichud- A Close Bond Negates The Leniency Of Ba'Ala Ba'Ir
Yichud- Does the Leniency of Ba’Ala BaIr Even Apply When The Husband Is At Work
Yichud- Can A Married Woman Be Secluded With A Man Outside of The Home
Yichud- Can One Woman Be Secluded With More Than One Man Such As House Workers (Plumber)
Yichud- Does The Prohibition of Seclusion Apply To Married Couples When The When The Wife is Needah
The Concept of Yichud- The Prohibition Of Being Alone With Others
The Prohibition Against Lending and Borrowing on Interest; Collecting a Debt if the Loan Was Given on Interest
To Whom Should One Lend Money To When Many Seek A Loan
The Misva to Lend Money
Must One Understand the Words of Kiddush to Fulfill His Obligation?
Waking One’s Parents; Relaying Distressing News to One’s Parents
The Value of Arising Early in the Morning and Staying Up Late at Night
Committing a Transgression in Order to Prevent Another Person From Sinning
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found