DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is In Memory of
 Solomon Graff

Dedicated By
Jay Graff

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 340 KB)
Allowing a Doorman to Open an Electric Door When One Enters a Building on Shabbat

In many apartment buildings and hotels today, a power-operated door is used in the main entrance. A doorman stands by the entrance and presses a button or activates a sensor that electronically opens the door when a resident or guest arrives. The question naturally arises as to whether a Jew may enter such a building on Shabbat. Halacha forbids allowing a gentile to perform Melacha (an act forbidden on Shabbat) on one's behalf on Shabbat. Seemingly, then, it would be forbidden for a Jew to allow a doorman to press the button to open the door for him when he arrives at the building on Shabbat.

In truth, however, Rav Shemuel Pinhasi (contemporary scholar in Israel), in his work Ve'daber Davar (4:10), rules that one may allow a doorman to activate the electric door on Shabbat. Since the possibility exists of opening the door manually, by turning the handle, we do not consider the gentile as performing Melacha on behalf of the Jew. The doorman chooses to open the door electronically for his own convenience, and not because the Jew specifically wishes that the door be opened in this fashion. As such, the gentile acts in his own interest, rather than in the Jew's, and the Jew may therefore allow him to open the door electronically.

The Jew may not, however, explicitly request that the doorman open the door for him on Shabbat. He may make such a request only indirectly, such as by saying, "The door is locked" or "I would like to come inside."

Summary: One may allow a gentile doorman to open a power-operated door on his behalf on Shabbat. It is forbidden, however, to explicitly request that he open the door; one must express this request indirectly, such as by saying, "The door is locked."

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Is There a Requirement Nowadays to Give Portions of a Slaughtered Animal to a Kohen?
Showing Respect to a Kohen
Lighting a Candle in Memory of the Deceased
Reciting She’hehiyanu Upon Seeing a Friend or Loved One for the First Time in 30 Days
Can a Minor be Counted as the Tenth Person for a Minyan?
Saying the Name of a City That is Named After a Pagan Deity
Does One Recite a Beracha When Seeing the President of the United States?
The Disqualification of a Kohen Who Accidentally Kills
Reciting Tikkun Hasot in the Afternoon During the Three Weeks, and Every Night
Sources of the Concept of Gematria
Does a Minor Recite Birkat Ha’gomel?
Praying at the Graves of the Righteous
The Prohibition Against Taking A Short Cut Through a Synagogue
Eating a Special Meal on Rosh Hodesh
Reciting “Va’ani Tefilati” and “Mizmor Shir” When Praying Minha Privately on Shabbat Afternoon
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found