DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 598 KB)
May One Eat Lunch Before Reciting Minha?

The Mishna in Masechet Shabbat (9b) establishes a prohibition against sitting down to a meal shortly before the time for reciting the Minha prayer. The Gemara discusses this Halacha and concludes that it refers to Minha Gedola, that is, the earliest period for reciting Minha, which begins 6.5 hours into the day. As such, it is forbidden to sit down to a meal from the point of six hours into the day until one recites Minha. For example, if the earliest time for Minha is 12:30 PM, one should not eat a meal after 12:00 until he first recites Minha.

The Gemara further notes that this Halacha applies even to an ordinary-sized meal, provided that it consists of bread. Even an ordinary meal, such as a sandwich, would be forbidden once the time for Minha arrives.

The question thus arises as to when a person should eat lunch. As the Gemara forbids eating a regular meal even early in the afternoon before reciting Minha, it would appear that it is forbidden to eat lunch until one recites Minha. Indeed, the practice in most Kollelim is to recite Minha early in the afternoon, before lunch, in accordance with the Gemara's conclusion. Hacham Ovadia Yosef in fact rules that it is preferable for all people to follow this practice, and recite Minha before eating lunch. This is also the ruling of Hacham Ben Sion Abba Shaul (Israel, 1923-1998), in his work Or Le'sion.

Nevertheless, Hacham Ovadia writes, those who pray Minha at a regular time each day, or have people who will remind them to recite Minha, and on this basis eat lunch before reciting Minha, have authorities on whom to rely. Even though it is preferable to recite Minha before eating lunch, a person may be lenient if he includes Minha in his regular routine or has people to remind him so that he does not forget to recite Minha.

Summary: One should preferably not eat a meal with bread for lunch until he recites Minha, though one may be lenient if he regularly recites Minha at a set time each day or has people to remind him to pray Minha.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Does One Make the Beracha of ‘SheAsa Li Kol Tzarki’ on Tisha BeAv
Tisha BeAv- The Prohibition of Laundering Clothes The Week of Tisha BeAv
Tisha BeAv- Seudat Hamafseket (The Last Meal Before The Fast)
Tisha BeAv- The Prohibition Taking Hair Cuts, and Cutting Nails During The Week of Tisha BeAv
Tisha BeAv- The Prohibition of Wearing Freshly Laundered Garments In The Week of Tisha BeAv
Tisha BeAv- Prohibitions During The First 9 Days of Av
Weddings and Engagements During the Three Weeks
Music During the Three Weeks
The Shehehiyanu Blessing During the Three Weeks
Reciting Tikun Hasot During the Three Weeks
The Miracle of 11 Tammuz, 5687 (1927)
Should One Avoid Having to Recite “She’hehiyanu” During the Three Weeks?
What Kind of Siyum Permits Eating Meat During the Nine Days?
Is it Permissible to Eat Synthetic Meat During the Nine Days
Torah Reading on a Fast Day in a Minyan of People Who are Not Fasting
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found