DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.53 MB)
Are Women Obligated to Drink on Purim?

The Gemara in Masechet Megila (7) introduces the obligation to rejoice on Purim through drinking intoxicating beverages: "A person is obligated to rejoice on Purim to the point where he cannot distinguish between Haman and Mordechai." This passage is generally understood to mean that one should drink wine until he becomes a bit dizzy so that he cannot think properly as he normally does.

The question arises as to whether this obligation applies to women. Women are included in all the Misvot of Purim, such as hearing the reading of the Megila, giving charity to the poor, sending Mishlo'ah Manot, and so on. Seemingly, then, they are likewise included in the obligation to become inebriated on Purim.

However, Rabbi Efrayim Greenblat of Memphis (a student of Rabbi Moshe Feinstein), in his work Rivevot Efrayim (1:458), rules that women should not, in fact, drink intoxicating beverages on Purim. He bases this ruling upon a number of arguments. Firstly, he explains the requirement to drink on Purim as a celebration we conduct in anticipation of the ultimate destruction of the descendants of Amalek. We drink not merely in celebration of the downfall of Haman, a member of Amalek who lived centuries ago, but also in eager anticipation of the day in the Messianic era when nothing will remain of Amalek, and there will be no more hatred towards the Jewish people. Accordingly, Rav Greenblat contends, since women are not included in the obligation to wage war against the nation of Amalek, they are likewise not included in the obligation to drink on Purim. This obligation relates to the ultimate destruction of Amalek, and thus it applies only to men, who bear the responsibility to wage this battle.

Secondly, Rav Greenblat draws a comparison between drinking on Purim and the obligation of candle lighting on Hanukah. The Hatam Sofer (Rabbi Moshe Sofer of Pressburg, Hungary, 1762-1839) ruled that even according to the Ashkenazic custom that each member of the household personally lights Hanukah candles, women fulfill their obligation through their husband's lighting. He explains that in Talmudic times, the Hanukah candles were lit outdoors, near the public domain, and it would be immodest for women to go to the public area to light Hanukah candles. Similarly, Rav Greenblat claims, it would be immodest for a woman to drink to the point of inebriation, and thus the obligation to drink on Purim does not apply to women.

Rav Greenblat points to a number of sources indicating that it is deemed inappropriate for a woman to drink intoxicating beverages. The Meiri (Talmudic commentator, France, 1249-1315), for example, makes such a comment in reference to the law of "Ben Sorer U'moreh" – the wayward son who is put to death due to his gluttonous behavior, ingesting excessive amounts of meat and wine. The Torah speaks only of a son, and not of daughters, because, as the Meiri explains, it is uncommon for a girl to be drawn after such gluttonous excesses. Rav Greenblat infers from this comment that it is not natural or proper for a woman to indulge in intoxicating beverages.

Another source is a comment the Sha'ar Ha'siyun (notes appended to the Mishna Berura commentary to the Shulhan Aruch), in the laws of Zimun (199:6). The Sha'ar Ha'siyun claims that women do not count towards a Zimun (quorum of three men required for the special Beracha before Birkat Ha'mazon) because the Zimun was traditionally conducted over a cup of wine, and it is unbecoming for a woman to drink wine. Rabbi Greenblat notes that if women were excluded from Zimun because it customarily involved drinking a single cup of wine, then certainly it would be inappropriate for a woman to drink and become inebriated, even as part of the Purim festivities.

We might also add that the Gemara presents the obligation to drink on Purim with the phrase, "Hayav Inash…" – "A man is obligated" – clearly suggesting that this obligation applies only to men.

We should note that although women are obligated to drink the four cups of wine at the Seder on Pesah, that drinking is not intended for the purpose of intoxication. Indeed, this Misva can be fulfilled by drinking grape juice. On Purim, however, the drinking is clearly done with the aim of becoming inebriated, which is inappropriate for women. It is thus customary for women not to drink alcoholic beverages on Purim for the purpose of getting drunk.

Summary: Although Halacha requires drinking intoxicating beverages on Purim, this obligation does not apply to women, and it is in fact inappropriate for a woman to drink intoxicating beverages, even on Purim.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Can Eliyahu HaNavee Come On Shabbat?
Is It Permissible To Have A Seuda Inside A Bet Kennesset
Is It Permissible To Change Biblical Verses from Singular to Plural Form
Is It Required To Repeat The Beracha Of LiHitatef BiTzitzit If Removing The Talit For Just A Short While
Is It Required To Make The Beracha Of LiHitatef BiTzitzit Again If The 1st Talit Was Found To Be Pasul (Improper)
Is One Required To Stand For An Elderly Lady or Scholarly Woman
Is It Permissible To Simply Answer Amen and Rely On Another's Beracha Of LiHitatef BiTzitzit
Granting Precedence to a Jew When Hiring
Is It Permissible To Give A Non-Kosher Turkey To A Goy For Their Holiday
Yichud- 1) Must An Onen Follow The Laws of Yichud, 2) War and Yichud
Yichud- Is It Permissible For A Man To Be Alone With A Lady On An Express Elevator In A Skyscraper
Yichud- Is It Permissible to Be Alone with Mother, Father, Daughter, Son, Brother, or Sister
Tzineeut and The Proper and Improper Ways Of Socializing With Friends
How Could We Pray To G-d That Korbanot Be Accepted, When Today We Do Not Have Korbanot?
Some Laws Regarding Visiting or Seeing a Cemetery
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found