DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 790 KB)
Succot- The Walls of the Sukka

A proper Sukka is defined by Halacha as a structure consisting of three walls that is covered by Sechach. Hacham Ovadia Yosef, in his Hazon Ovadia – Sukkot (p. 1; listen to audio for precise citation), writes that any material may be used for the walls of the Sukka. Unlike the material used for the Sechach, which must meet certain requirements, the walls may be made from any material. Thus, for example, a person can use barrels or the side of a large chest as one of the walls of the Sukka, even though such objects are susceptible to Tum'a, ritual purity (as opposed to Sechach, which must not be susceptible to Tum'a).

Hacham Ovadia adds that the only restriction that applies to the walls of the Sukka is that they do not sway back and forth when exposed to an ordinary gust of wind. Even if there is no wind in the particular location where the Sukka stands, if the walls are made from sheets and the like and would sway in an ordinary wind, the Sukka is not valid for use. The walls need not be strong enough to withstand hurricane-force winds, but they must be able to remain in place when subjected to common gusts of wind.

Hacham Ovadia rules that such walls should not be used for the Sukka even if they are tightly tied to the Sukka's frame such that they do not sway in the wind. Sheets tied to a frame have the tendency to become loose, and the person might not realize when this occurs. He will then be eating in an invalid Sukka – which is, in essence, the same as eating outside a Sukka – and reciting a Beracha Le'vatala ("wasted" Beracha). Hacham Ovadia therefore maintains that one should use walls that are strong and sturdy, such as walls made from wood, fiberglass and the like, rather than use materials such as canvas that sway in the wind. This is the view of several other authorities, as well, including Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach (Jerusalem, 1910-1995).

Summary: Any material may be used for the walls of the Sukka, provided that it does not sway back and forth when subjected to an ordinary wind. Even if one ties the material tightly to the Sukka's frame such that it remains in place in the wind, one should not use such a Sukka. Instead, one should use a Sukka made with strong, sturdy walls, such as from wood or fiberglass, that can withstand an ordinary gust of wind.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Hanukah – Lighting the Candles With Genuine Joy; Lighting With a Wax Candle
Hanukah – Spinning the Dreidel; Giving Gifts to Children and Teachers
The Custom Among Some Syrian Jews to Light an Extra Candle on Hanukah
Hanukah Candles – Arranging the Candles in a Straight Line; the Proper Place for Lighting
Chanukah- Should One Skip Al HaNissim To Catch Up for Nakdishach
Proper Handling of Leftover Oil and Wicks from the Hanukah Lights
Chanukah- Fasting, Eulogies and Mourning on Chanukah
Hanukah – If the Wrong Section From the Torah Was Read on Hanukah
If One Travels on Hanukah to a Place Without a Jewish Community
Hanukah – Must One Light the Candles Again if They are Extinguished After Lighting?
Hanukah – The Use of Floating Wicks
Hanukah – Reciting Hallel in a House of Mourning; Reciting “Mizmor Shir Hanukat Ha’bayit”
Hanukah – Does One Recite Shehehiyanu the First Time He Lights if He Did Not Light on the First Night?
Hanukah – The Halachot of Candle Lighting for Travelers
Hanukah – Is it Preferable to Use New Wicks Each Night, or to Reuse the Wicks From the Previous Night?
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found