DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 790 KB)
What is The Beracha on Rice with Vegetables and When Eating Apples with Bananas

The Ben Ish Chai (Rabbi Yosef Chayim of Baghdad, 1833-1909), in Parashat Pinchas (16), addresses the case of a person who partakes of a fruit over which one recites "Ha'etz" according to all views, as well as a fruit over which there is a dispute as to which Beracha one recites. The status of bananas, for example, is subject to a debate as to whether it requires the Beracha of "Borei Peri Ha'adama" or "Borei Peri Ha'etz." Our practice follows the ruling of the Shulchan Aruch in O"H siman203:3 that one recites "Borei Peri Ha'adama" over bananas, but there are authorities who disagree and require "Ha'etz." Thus, when one eats a banana with another fruit – such as an apple – over which all views require reciting "Borei Peri Ha'etz," he faces a Halachic dilemma of sorts. If he recites "Borei Peri Ha'etz" over the apple, then according to the authorities who require "Ha'etz" over bananas, he should not then recite a Beracha over the banana, since it was covered by the Beracha recited over the apple. According to the other views, however, he must of course recite "Ha'adama" before eating the banana.

The Ben Ish Chai rules that in such a case one should recite "Ha'etz" over the apple with the specific intent that the Beracha does not cover the banana. He thereby avoids this dilemma and may recite "Ha'adama" over the banana according to all views.

A similar dilemma arises in a situation where one eats whole-grain rice with vegetables. Although we follow the Shulchan Aruch's ruling in O"H siman 208:7 to recite "Borei Minei Mezonot" over whole-grain rice, other authorities maintain that one should recite "Ha'adama." In this case, too, one who first recites "Ha'adama" over the vegetables encounters the Halachic question of whether or not to recite a Beracha over the rice, as according to some authorities the rice was covered by the Beracha recited over the vegetables. Chacham Ovadia Yosef rules (in Chazon Ovadia – Laws of Tu B'Shvat, p. 277) that here, too, one should recite "Ha'adama" over the vegetables with clear intention that the Beracha should not apply to the rice. He may then recite "Mezonot" over the rice without concern.

Summary: One who eats an apple and a banana should first recite "Ha'etz" over the apple with the clear intent that the Beracha should not cover the banana; after eating the apple, he should then recite "Ha'adama" and eat the banana. If a person eats whole-grain rice with vegetables, he should recite "Ha'adama" over the vegetables with the intent that it does not cover the rice. After eating some vegetables, he should recite "Mezonot" over the rice.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Is There a Requirement Nowadays to Give Portions of a Slaughtered Animal to a Kohen?
Showing Respect to a Kohen
Lighting a Candle in Memory of the Deceased
Reciting She’hehiyanu Upon Seeing a Friend or Loved One for the First Time in 30 Days
Can a Minor be Counted as the Tenth Person for a Minyan?
Saying the Name of a City That is Named After a Pagan Deity
Does One Recite a Beracha When Seeing the President of the United States?
The Disqualification of a Kohen Who Accidentally Kills
Reciting Tikkun Hasot in the Afternoon During the Three Weeks, and Every Night
Sources of the Concept of Gematria
Does a Minor Recite Birkat Ha’gomel?
Praying at the Graves of the Righteous
The Prohibition Against Taking A Short Cut Through a Synagogue
Eating a Special Meal on Rosh Hodesh
Reciting “Va’ani Tefilati” and “Mizmor Shir” When Praying Minha Privately on Shabbat Afternoon
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found