DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 428 KB)
Passover- Is It Permissible To Drink Milk On Pesach From A Goy Owned Cow Which Consumed Hametz On Pesach

The Ben Ish Chai (Rabbi Yosef Chayim of Baghdad, 1835-1909) rules that one may not drink milk produced by a gentile on Pesach, given the possibility that the cow may have been fed Hametz. Drinking the milk that a cow produces from the Hametz it was fed amounts to deriving Hana'a (benefit) from Hametz, which is, of course, forbidden on Pesach.

Chacham Ovadia Yosef in; Halichot Olam, Helek 1, page 305, however, disagrees with this ruling of the Ben Ish Chai. He cites the Beit Efrayim who addresses this very question and allows drinking milk produced by a gentile during Pesach, for three reasons. Firstly, the Hametz belongs to the gentile when it is fed to the cow, and it is perfectly permissible for a gentile to feed his animal Hametz on Pesach. Secondly, the animal eats many different kinds of foods, and not only Hametz, and so the milk is not necessarily produced specifically from Hametz. Finally, it is uncertain altogether with the milk one purchases was produced by a cow that was fed Hametz. Therefore, Chacham Ovadia rules that one may, in fact, drink milk produced by a gentile on Pesach. Nevertheless, some people abide by the stringency of the Ben Ish Chai, and make a point of purchasing all their milk before Pesach. Strictly speaking, however, this is not necessary.

It should be noted that this discussion does not involve the separate issue of Chalav Yisrael – whether it is forbidden to drink milk generally if was not produced by a Jew, which is a different topic entirely.

In conclusion, then, in situations where it is permissible in general to drink milk produced by gentiles, one may do so even on Pesach, and even if the gentile produced the milk on Pesach. Nevertheless, there are those who are stringent in this regard and purchase all their milk for Pesach before the holiday.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Hanukah – Lighting the Candles With Genuine Joy; Lighting With a Wax Candle
Hanukah – Spinning the Dreidel; Giving Gifts to Children and Teachers
The Custom Among Some Syrian Jews to Light an Extra Candle on Hanukah
Hanukah Candles – Arranging the Candles in a Straight Line; the Proper Place for Lighting
Chanukah- Should One Skip Al HaNissim To Catch Up for Nakdishach
Proper Handling of Leftover Oil and Wicks from the Hanukah Lights
Chanukah- Fasting, Eulogies and Mourning on Chanukah
Hanukah – If the Wrong Section From the Torah Was Read on Hanukah
If One Travels on Hanukah to a Place Without a Jewish Community
Hanukah – Must One Light the Candles Again if They are Extinguished After Lighting?
Hanukah – The Use of Floating Wicks
Hanukah – Reciting Hallel in a House of Mourning; Reciting “Mizmor Shir Hanukat Ha’bayit”
Hanukah – Does One Recite Shehehiyanu the First Time He Lights if He Did Not Light on the First Night?
Hanukah – The Halachot of Candle Lighting for Travelers
Hanukah – Is it Preferable to Use New Wicks Each Night, or to Reuse the Wicks From the Previous Night?
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found