DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is For Refuah Shelemah for
 Rita Rina Braha bt Emilie

Dedicated By
Family

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 858 KB)
Hanukah – Does One Recite Shehehiyanu the First Time He Lights if He Did Not Light on the First Night?

An interesting question arises concerning the Berachot over the Hanukah candle lighting in the case of somebody who is away from home on the first night. The Halacha in such a case is that the person’s wife, or another Shali’ah (agent), lights the candles in his home, and he fulfills the Misva through that lighting. Of course, on the first night of Hanukah, in addition to the standard two Berachot over the Misva ("Lehadlik Ner Hanukah" and "She’asa Nissim La’abotenu"), we also recite a third Beracha – "Shehehiyanu." The question thus arises as to whether one should recite this third Beracha on the second night of Hanukah if he did not personally light Hanukah candles on the first night. One might argue that just as one fulfills his obligation of lighting through his wife’s lighting, he similarly fulfills his obligation of
"Shehehiyanu" through her recitation of the Beracha. As such, he does not recite the Beracha when he lights Hanukah candles on the second night of the holiday. This is, indeed, the view taken by the Magen Abraham (Rav Abraham Gombiner, Poland, 1637-1682), in Siman 676 (listen to audio recording for precise citation).

Many other authorities, however, disagree. The Peri Hadash (Rav Hizkiya De Silva, 1656-1695) writes that if one was traveling at sea on the first night of Hanukah and fulfilled his obligation through his wife’s lighting, he must recite all three Berachot when he lights the next night. He writes that the Beracha of "Shehehiyanu" resembles Birkot Ha’nehenin (Berachot over personal benefit, such as Berachot over food), which cannot be fulfilled through the recitation of another person. Thus, even though one can fulfill the Misva of Hanukah candle lighting through somebody else’s lighting, one cannot fulfill the obligation of "Shehehiyanu" through somebody else’s recitation of the Beracha. This is also the view of the Bayit Hadash (Rav Yoel Sirkis, Poland, 1561-1640) and the Elya Rabba (Rav Eliyahu Shapiro of Prague, 1660-1712).

This is the consensus among contemporary Poskim, as well. Rav Shemuel Wosner, in Shebet Halevi (vol. 4, 68; listen to audio recording for precise citation) writes that reciting "Shehehiyanu" constitutes a "Hobat Ha’guf" – a personal obligation that cannot be executed through a proxy. This is also the view taken by Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, as cited in the work Ribebot Efrayim (vol. 6, 410; listen to audio recording for precise citation). Rav Elyashiv addresses the case of somebody who was away the first seven nights of Hanukah and lights for the first time on the eighth and final night. Even in such a case, Rav Elyashiv writes, he should recite "Shehehiyanu" since he did not fulfill his obligation to recite this Beracha through his wife’s or agent’s recitation.

Hacham Ovadia Yosef, in Hazon Ovadia – Hanukah (p. 138; listen to audio recording for precise citation) cites both views, and concludes that Halacha follows the second view, that one must recite "Shehehiyanu" in such a case. This is, indeed, the accepted Halacha.

Summary: If a person is away from home on the first night or first several nights of Hanukah, and his wife or somebody else lights in his stead at home, he recites the Beracha of "Shehehiyanu" the first time he lights for himself.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Removing a Teabag From a Teacup on Shabbat
Borer – Removing a Fly From Soup or From a Beverage on Shabbat
Halachot of Borer as They Apply to Eating Soup
Borer – Separating Food Which One Dislikes From Food Which He Likes
Borer – If One Separated Food and Then Decides Not to Eat
Borer – Peeling More Fruits Than are Needed for the Current Meal
Borer – Separating Foods for Somebody Else
Borer – Separating Foods That are Together on a Plate But Not Mixed
Borer – Removing Edible Food From Inedible Food
Borer – The Status of Food That Was Separated in Forbidden Fashion on Shabbat
Borer – Peeling on Onion on Shabbat
Is it Permissible to Insulate a Pot of Food With Towels on Shabbat?
If A Blech Had Been Placed on a Stove Before Shabbat and Then Fell Off
The Shabbat Haftara Reading
May One Open a Door on Shabbat if it Has Shelves with Mukseh Items?
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found