DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 968 KB)
Putting a Liquid or Solid Food into a Keli Sheni on Shabbat

In Hilchot Shabbat, the vessel that was heated on the fire is called "Keli Rishon"-the first vessel. If the hot contents were poured into a second vessel, that vessel is called a "Keli Sheni." Even if the contents of the Keli Sheni are still be very hot, the Halacha states a general principle that "Keli Sheni Enno Mevashel"-putting raw food in the second vessel does not constitute cooking on Shabbat. For example, if one poured hot water from the urn into a teacup, the teacup is a Keli Sheni, and therefore it is permitted to put a raw lemon inside the hot water. This is the conclusion of Hacham Ovadia and Hacham Benison.

The question is why doesn’t the Keli Sheni cook? Aren’t its contents also very hot, like the Keli Rishon? Tosafot (Shabbat 40b) explain that although the contents may be hot, the walls of the vessel are cold and this allows it to cool rapidly, dampening its ability to cook. Based on this, the Maharshal (R. Shlomo Luria, 1510-1573), as understood by the Shach, writes a phenomenal Chidush: If there would be a Keli Sheni that was not in contact with the cool walls of the vessel, it would cook a raw food placed on it. That is, if one took a potato or a piece of meat from a Keli Rishon and placed it on a plate, which is the Keli Sheni, the meat is not being cooled by the walls; it is standing alone as a "Davar Gush"-a solid mass. Consequently, the piece of hot food is treated as a Keli Rishon, and it would be prohibited to apply raw spices or other raw foods to the hot food on the plate.

The Rema (in Shulhan Aruch and in Torat Hatat) looks at this in a different way. He maintains that if the piece of hot food is placed in a Keli Sheni, then it also has the status of Keli Sheni and cannot cook another raw food. Accordingly, one may pour cold gravy over the hot food, since it is only a Keli Sheni.

The Mishna Berura (Rav Yisrael Meir Kagan of Radin, 1839-1933, in Siman 318:45) and the Kaf HaHaim (Rav Yaakob Haim Sofer, Baghdad-Israel, 1870-1939) rule in accordance with the Maharshal that a "Davar HaGush" does cook in a Keli Sheni. On the other hand, Hacham Bension (Vol. 2) writes that the custom of the Sepharadim is to be lenient and not distinguish between a liquid and a solid mass in a Keli Sheni. This is also the opinion of Hacham Ovadia in Hazon Ovadia (Vol. 4). Hacham David, in his new Halacha Berura, also brings this position, although he adds, "Hamachmir Tavo Alav Beracha"- it is praiseworthy to be strict.

SUMMARY
One may pour cold gravy or raw spices on a hot solid food in a Keli Sheni.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
If the Hazan Forgot to Recite Ya’aleh Ve’yabo During the Repetition of the Amida on Rosh Hodesh
Should Two Kaddishim be Recited if a Shiur is Given Immediately Before Arbit?
Reciting “Yiheyu Le’rason Imreh Fi” at the End of the Amida
The Kaddish Before Baruch She’amar
The Value of Praying “Vatikin” and Studying Torah Before Prayer
The Importance and Significance of Birkat Ha’lebana
The Custom Among Syrian Jews Regarding the Text of “Ve’la’minim” and Other Portions of the Amida
Adding Prayers for Forgiveness and for One’s Livelihood in “Shema Kolenu”
If One Mistakenly Recited “Morid Ha’tal” Instead of “Mashib Ha’ru’ah U’morid Ha’geshem”
Should a Mourner be Called for an Aliya if He is the Only Kohen in Attendance?
May Birkat Kohanim be Recited if a Non-Jew is Present
If a Kohen Was Mistakenly Called for the Second Aliya; Calling Kohanim for Later Aliyot
How Should the Aliyot be Arranged in a Minyan of Only Kohanim, or if There is Only One Yisrael?
Birkat Kohanim – The Hazan’s Announcement of “Kohanim”; If There is One Kohen or No Kohanim Present
Birkat Kohanim in a Place Without a Sefer Torah; One Who Enters the Synagogue During Birkat Kohanim; Reciting Birkat Kohanim Several Times in One Day
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found