DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 1.18 MB)
Is It Permissible to Put Baked Bread on a Blech to Make Toast?

The Poskim discuss whether it is permitted to place bread on the Blech in order for it to become toast. A number of Poskim rule that it is prohibited, each giving a different reason. The first one to address this issues wat the Shoel U’Meshiv (Rabbi Yosef Shaul Nathansohn, 1808–1875, Poland). Based on the Rambam (Shabbat 9:3), who writes that hardening a soft material is a Tolada (corollary) of Mevashel (cooking), he concludes that it prohibited. Hacham Bension has a different understanding why it forbidden. He says that any enhancement of a food is considered Bishul. Just as there are opinions that "Yesh Bishul Ahar Afiya"-one may not cook a food after it has been baked-since the baking enhances the food, so too, the toasting adds a new level to the bread and is forbidden. The Ben Ish Hai (Rav Yosef Haim of Baghdad, 1833-1909), in Rav Pa’alim, prohibits making toast because of "Makeh B’Patish"- adding the finishing touch to the bread. The Menuhat Ahaba (Rabbi Moshe Halevi, Israel, 1961-2001-vol. 2) also prohibits making toast. He argues that the general principle of "En Bishul Ahar Bishul"-there is no cooking after cooking- only applies when the second cooking does not add to the previous cooking. But here, regarding toast, the normal way to make toast is to apply a second baking to the already baked bread, and therefore the bread is considered raw vis-ŕ-vis the second baking and is prohibited.

Hacham Ovadia (Hazon Ovadia vol. 4) and Hacham David (Halacha Berura 318) disagree and hold that it is permissible to make toast. They refute the arguments of the Poskim who prohibit it. Regarding the Shoel U’Meshiv’s reading of the Rambam, they argue and say the Rambam was only talking about the specific cases he mentioned-i.e. hardening metal, wood, wax and tar-not food. Regarding the Ben Ish Hai’s application of "Makeh B’Patish," the Be'ur Halacha (Rav Yisrael Meir Kagan of Radin, 1839-1933) clearly holds that it does not apply to food. They also reject Hacham Bension’s comparison to "Yesh Bishul Ahar Afiya," since that refers to adding a different process of cooking after baking, whereas here it is just a continuation of the same baking process. They also disagree with the Menuhat Ahaba’s Hidush that the bread is considered raw. It is too extreme. According to that, anytime a second cooking enhances an already cooked food, it would be prohibited.

The conclusion is that it is permitted to make toast, based on the general principle of "En Afiya Ahar Afiya"-There is no problem baking an already baked food.

SUMMARY
It is permitted to make toast on Shabbat by placing bread on the Blech or hotplate.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
If the Hazan Forgot to Recite Ya’aleh Ve’yabo During the Repetition of the Amida on Rosh Hodesh
Should Two Kaddishim be Recited if a Shiur is Given Immediately Before Arbit?
Reciting “Yiheyu Le’rason Imreh Fi” at the End of the Amida
The Kaddish Before Baruch She’amar
The Value of Praying “Vatikin” and Studying Torah Before Prayer
The Importance and Significance of Birkat Ha’lebana
The Custom Among Syrian Jews Regarding the Text of “Ve’la’minim” and Other Portions of the Amida
Adding Prayers for Forgiveness and for One’s Livelihood in “Shema Kolenu”
If One Mistakenly Recited “Morid Ha’tal” Instead of “Mashib Ha’ru’ah U’morid Ha’geshem”
Should a Mourner be Called for an Aliya if He is the Only Kohen in Attendance?
May Birkat Kohanim be Recited if a Non-Jew is Present
If a Kohen Was Mistakenly Called for the Second Aliya; Calling Kohanim for Later Aliyot
How Should the Aliyot be Arranged in a Minyan of Only Kohanim, or if There is Only One Yisrael?
Birkat Kohanim – The Hazan’s Announcement of “Kohanim”; If There is One Kohen or No Kohanim Present
Birkat Kohanim in a Place Without a Sefer Torah; One Who Enters the Synagogue During Birkat Kohanim; Reciting Birkat Kohanim Several Times in One Day
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found