DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 572 KB)
Can One Recite Boreh Nefashot If He Does Not Have The Ability To Say Meen Shalosh When Required

A person who partook of a "Kezayit" of fruit from among the special species (grapes, figs, pomegranates, olives and dates) must recite the Beracha of "Al Ha'etz" after eating.

If a person does not remember the text of this Beracha and does not have access to a Siddur, should he recite "Boreh Nefashot" in place of "Al Ha'etz"?

Hacham Ovadia Yosef addresses this question in his work Yabia Omer (vol. 2, Orah Haim 12:7) and rules that a person in such a case should not recite any Beracha, as "Boreh Nefashot" cannot serve as a substitute for "Al Ha'etz." Nevertheless, he writes, if a person in this situation did recite "Boreh Nefashot," then he has, post facto, fulfilled his obligation. As such, if he then gains access to a Siddur, he should not recite "Al Ha'etz," since he has fulfilled his requirement by reciting "Boreh Nefashot," despite the fact that optimally he should not have done so.

This ruling is predicated on the famous Halachic principle of "Safek Berachot Le'Hakel," which dictates that one should not recite a Beracha in a case where he is unsure whether it is warranted. The question of whether or not "Boreh Nefashot" can serve as a substitute for "Al Ha'etz" is subject to a debate among the Halachic authorities, and therefore optimally one should not recite "Boreh Nefashot" in place of "Al Ha'etz," even if he has no possibility of reciting "Al Ha'etz." But if one did recite "Boreh Nefashot" in place of "Al Ha'etz," then since according to some authorities he has fulfilled his obligation, he should not recite "Al Ha'etz" if he then gains access to a Siddur.

It should be noted that Rabbi Moshe Halevi, in his work Birkat Hashem, disputes this ruling and maintains that according to the accepted Halacha the Beracha of "Boreh Nefashot" can never satisfy one's requirement to recite "Al Ha'etz." In his view, if one recited "Boreh Nefashot" when he was required to recite "Al Ha'etz," he has not fulfilled his obligation and must therefore recite "Al Ha'etz" if the opportunity arises.

In any event, we follow the ruling of Hacham Ovadia Yosef that although one should not recite "Boreh Nefashot" in place of "Al Ha'etz," if one did so he is considered as having fulfilled his requirement, and should not recite "Al Ha'etz" if the opportunity arises.

Summary: If a person who is required to recite "Al Ha'etz" does not remember the text and has no access to a Siddur, he should not recite any Beracha. If he mistakenly recited "Boreh Nefashot" in place of "Al Ha'etz," then he is considered as having fulfilled his requirement and therefore should not recite "Al Ha'etz" even if gains access to a Siddur.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Shabbat – Ensuring That the Countertop is Dry Before Putting Down a Hot Pot
Reheating Solid Food With Some Liquid on Shabbat
Is it Permissible to Eat Soup That Was Reheated on Shabbat?
Placing Cold Liquid Near the Stove on Shabbat
Placing a Raw Food Next to a Hot Food on a Plate on Shabbat
Can A Man or Woman Eat or Drink Prior To Kiddush On Shabbat Morning
Asking a Gentile to Write on One’s Behalf on Shabbat
Is It Permissible To Take Vitamins On Shabbat
Tying Knots on Shabbat-Basic Understandings of Restrictions and Permissions
Is It Permissible To Trap Pets in the House on Shabbat?
Is It Permissible To Eat A Meal Just Prior To Shabbat
Is It Permissible to Lace Shoes on Shabbat?
Is It Permissible to Set Up a Mousetrap on Shabbat?
May One Move a Garment on Shabbat if There is Money in the Pocket?
Is It Permissible To Cover A Pot with its Cover or Tin Foil or Other on Shabbat
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found