DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Halacha is For Refuah Shelemah for
 Yehuda ben Rivka

Dedicated By
Michael Mordechai ben Avraham

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
      
(File size: 802 KB)
May One Place a Bag of Raw Rice Inside the Cholent in the Crockpot from Before Shabbat?

Many people prepare cholent (or "Hamin") for Shabbat by placing meat, potatoes and other foods and flavoring into the crockpot before Shabbat, and letting it cook until Shabbat morning. Sometimes, one may wish to cook another food, such as rice, by placing it in a cooking bag inside the cholent. The rice remains separate from the cholent, as it is held in the bag, and cooks from the heat of the cholent cooking in the crockpot.

At first glance, we might forbid this practice on the grounds of "Hatmana," or "insulating." Halacha forbids insulating food in a heat source even before Shabbat, if the insulation increases the food’s temperature. In the case described, one insulates the rice inside the hot cholent, which obviously adds heat to the rice and enables it to cook, which would seemingly constitute a violation of "Hatmana." Indeed, Rabbi Moshe Halevi (Israel, 1961-2001), in his work Menuhat Ahaba, forbade putting food in a cooking bag inside the cholent pot before Shabbat.

Other authorities, however, including Hacham Ovadia Yosef, Hacham Ben Sion Abba Shaul (Israel, 1923-1998) and the Hazon Ish (Rabbi Avaham Yeshaya Karelitz, 1879-1954), ruled leniently on this issue. The prohibition of "Hatmana" does not apply to insulating food in other food. The classic case of "Hatmana" is wrapping a pot with cloths and fabrics such as towels, and enclosing food with other food does not violate this prohibition. As such, one may insulate the rice inside the cholent before Shabbat.

One might have argued that "Hatmana" should apply in this case, since the rice is not insulated directly in the cholent, but rather in a bag. Insulating with a bag indeed constitutes "Hatmana," and thus seemingly this should be forbidden. This argument, however, fails to take into account the fact that the bag is not intended as an insulating material. The person placed the rice in the bag not for the bag to add heat, but simply to keep the rice separate from the cholent. It is the cholent, not the rice, which serves the purpose of insulation, and thus since "Hatmana" does not apply when insulating with food, this arrangement would not violate "Hatmana."

Summary: It is permissible to place a cooking bag with raw food inside one’s cholent in the crockpot before Shabbat to cook and be ready for the Shabbat morning meal.


 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Desecrating Shabbat in Cases of Severe Internal Pain
Taking Preventative Medication on Shabbat
Is it Permissible to Take Pain Relievers on Shabbat?
Minimizing Shabbat Desecration in Situations of Life-Threatening Danger
May One Move Candlesticks on Shabbat After the Candles Have Burned Out?
Paying For A Hotel Room Over Shabbat
“Mukseh Mahamat Hisaron Kis” – Moving Expensive Items on Shabbat
The Friday Night Prayer Service According to the Custom of Halab
May One Recite “Ha’mosi” on Shabbat for Somebody Else After He Had Already Eaten?
The Rule of “Pesik Resheh” – A Permissible Act That Will Inevitably Result in a Shabbat Violation
Kiddush – Having in Mind to Fulfill the Obligation
Should One Stand or Sit for the Friday Night Kiddush & Drinking of the Wine?
Customs for Mosa’eh Shabbat
Making Seltzer on Shabbat
Using on Shabbat Hot Water That Was Heated Permissibly on Shabbat
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found