DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 3.35 MB)
Grinding Spices on Shabbat

The Rambam writes that crushing pepper corns on Shabbat is a Torah prohibition of the Melacha of Tohen-grinding. However, Maran, in Siman 321:7, rules that if one grinds with two Shinuim-deviations from the normal way of grinding, it is permitted. For example, he uses the back of a knife or the bottom of the glass to pulverize pepper corns or garlic and also does it on a table as opposed to a bowl.

The Ben Ish Hai writes that the custom of Baghdad was to be lenient to grind with even one Shinui. Nevertheless, Hacham Ovadia, Hacham Bension, the Menuhat Ahaba and all the other Poskim rule that one must be strict and grind only with two Shinuim.

When grinding with two Shinuim, there is no need to do so immediately before consumption, as opposed to chopping vegetables in a regular fashion which is only permitted within half an hour of the meal. Of course, his intent must be to grind the spice for use on Shabbat, and not prepare for after Shabbat.

Some people crush spices, such as pepper corns, in a cloth so that the fragments don’t scatter. The Poskim discuss whether this constitutes a problem of "Molid Reha"-imbuing an item with a fragrance- which is an Issur D’rabanan (Rabbinic prohibition). The Mishna Berura rules that there is no issue, since that is not his intent-Davar She’eno Mitkaven. Hacham Ovadia writes that although he does not intend to imbue the cloth with a smell, it is a Pesik Resheh-an inevitable outcome, which is usually prohibited. Nevertheless, it is permitted, since Molid Reha is only a D’rabanan, and it is "Lo Ichpat Leh "-he does not care about the result. This is especially true, since the Rambam did not even bring this prohibition of Molid Reha.


SUMMARY
It is permitted to grind pepper corns or garlic with two Shinuim-using the back of a knife or a glass directly on the table-even for consumption at a late time on Shabbat. There is no problem to grind on a cloth, even though the cloth receives the smell of the spices.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Use of Blech or Hotplate on Shabbat-Summary
Is It Permissible to Place a Cover on a Pot on a Blech on Shabbat?
Employing a Non-Jewish Maid on Shabbat
May a Jew Engage a Non-Jew to Invest on his Behalf on Shabbat?
May a Non-Jewish Technician Perform Repairs in a Jew’s Home on Shabbat?
Drying Dishes on Shabbat
Drying One’s Hands on a Towel on Shabbat
Cleaning Shoes on Shabbat
Using a Timer to Activate a Hotplate on Shabbat
The Difference Between Hatmana and Placing Food on a “Blech”
Hatmana: Covering Pots on the Blech
Hatmana: Foil –Placing Wrapped Foods on the Blech
Hatmana: Covering Pots on a Blech with Towels
Hatmana: Warming a Baby Bottle
Hatmana-Wrapped Foods in a Pot
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found