DailyHalacha.com for Mobile Devices Now Available

Click Here to Sponsor Daily Halacha
"Delivered to Over 6000 Registered Recipients Each Day"

      
(File size: 378 KB)
Borer- Is A Sink Drain Strainer Permissible On Shabbat Even Though It May Be Separating And Selecting Out Foods

The question was asked in regards to the laws of Borer, which is the prohibition of selecting on Shabbat. In most households, a small strainer is found at the drain in the kitchen sink, and its purpose is to separate out food particles in order to prevent the food particles from clogging the drain. So there is a question that we need to address in regards to Shabbat and sink strainers. Is it considered a transgression in the laws of Borer when spilling out vegetable soup or other lqiuidy items into the sink? The strainer is separating the food particles from the liquid. Seemingly this is a transgression because a Keli (vessel) is being used to select, and using a vessel to select is forbidden on Shabbat from the Torah.

This question was addressed by Rabbi Moshe HaLevi in his book ‘Menuhat A’Hava’, and it is also brought down in the book ‘Shemirat Shabbat Kilchita’ written by Rabbi Yehoshua Neuwirth. Both agree that it is permissible to have the strainer in the drain of the sink, and it is not a transgression of Borer. They explain that one is not selecting good from bad or bad from good in this case, and therefore Borer does not apply. A person is really discarding all the contents of the food, both liquid and solids, and as such it is all considered bad (Pisolet). The strainer is separating the contents in order to prevent clogging in the pipes, but that is not a violation of Borer. The laws of Borer only apply when selecting good content from bad, or bad from good. In this case, all is bad, hence the laws of Borer are not applicable.

Halacha Lema’ase, the use of a sink drain strainer is not a transgression of the laws of Borer.

 


Recent Daily Halachot...
Reciting Arbit Before Sunset When Praying Privately
Is It Permissible To Pray Arbit B'Yachid Early Before Sunset
Daily Reading of the Ketoret To Bring The End To A Plague
Tefillin and Birkat Kohanim During Minha on Fast Days
The Special Significance of Alenu
May One Person Recite Birkat HaGomel For Many In The Synagogue?
Is it Considered Praying B’Tzibur if One prays a Different Prayer than the Congregation
Sitting Near Somebody Praying the Amidah
The Proper Way To Vocalize The Amidah
Answering Kadish and Amen During Pesukeh D'zimra
The Meaning of the Term “Pesukeh De’zimra”
Answering to Kaddish or Kedusha After Reciting “Ado-nai Sefatai Tiftah”
Reciting Hodu Before Shaharit
Reciting Shema During the Korbanot Section of the Prayer Service
If One Comes Late to the Synagogue and Will Not Complete the Amida Before the Hazan Reaches Modim
Page of 239
3585 Halachot found